Skip to content

Fantasy: 12-team mock draft with analysis

Charles LeClaire-USA TODAY Sports

Get ready for your season with theScore's 2018 Fantasy Football Draft Kit.

Mock Drafts

theScore staff took part in a 12-team, 12-round mock to help provide a glimpse at what your drafts might look like and give some insight on what to watch for in each round.

This is a standard (non-PPR) scoring league with the following roster spots: QB, RB, RB, WR, WR, WR, TE, FLEX, BN, BN, BN, BN. We left off defenses and kickers since they normally get selected in the final two rounds.

Draft Participants: Alex Chippin, Dan Wilkins, Jack Browne, David P. Woods, Caitlyn Holroyd, Gino Bottero, Mitch Sanderson, Justin Boone, Esten McLaren, Mike Alessandrini, Sean Tomlinson, Dan Levine.

Round 1

Pick Player Owner
1 Ezekiel Elliott (RB1) Chippin
2 Todd Gurley (RB2) Wilkins
3 David Johnson (RB3) Browne
4 Le'Veon Bell (RB4) Woods
5 Antonio Brown (WR1) Holroyd
6 Alvin Kamara (RB5) Bottero
7 Leonard Fournette (RB6) Sanderson
8 DeAndre Hopkins (WR2) Boone
9 Kareem Hunt (RB7) McLaren
10 Julio Jones (WR3) Alessandrini
11 Odell Beckham Jr. (WR4) Tomlinson
12 Saquon Barkley (RB8) Levine

Round 1: A big surprise off the top as Elliott is selected before Gurley and Bell, who are normally the first two picks. Gurley, Bell, and even Johnson play major roles in their team's passing attacks, giving them higher ceilings and floors. It's possible Elliott will have a career year in 2018, but he'll need to nearly double his volume as a receiver to eclipse the other elite backs ... With my top-six rushers off the board, I went with Hopkins - a dominant wideout coming off a 96-catch, 1,378-yard, 13-touchdown campaign. Hopkins also gets Deshaun Watson back under center after the duo showed impressive chemistry early last year.

Round 2

Pick Player Owner
13 Melvin Gordon (RB9) Levine
14 Michael Thomas (WR5) Tomlinson
15 Dalvin Cook (RB10) Alessandrini
16 Devonta Freeman (RB11) McLaren
17 Keenan Allen (WR6) Boone
18 LeSean McCoy (RB12) Sanderson
19 A.J. Green (WR7) Bottero
20 Davante Adams (WR8) Holroyd
21 Mike Evans (WR9) Woods
22 Joe Mixon (RB13) Browne
23 Jordan Howard (RB14) Wilkins
24 Doug Baldwin (WR10) Chippin

Round 2: Even in a 12-team league, there's a plethora of talent deep into the second round. Gordon, Thomas, and Allen could easily be worthy of first-round consideration ... McCoy has delivered monster fantasy campaigns in the past, but entering his age-30 season, he'll face a higher degree of difficulty playing in an offense that lacks talent at every position. Downgrades to his blockers could be most problematic as the Bills lost the entire left side of their offensive line. Volume is his only hope of countering a likely drop in efficiency ... Mixon sneaks into the second round, in part thanks to the arrival of McCoy's former left tackle, Cordy Glenn. The Bengals invested in their offensive line in hopes of kickstarting the offense after a down year. The upside is there for a breakout season from Mixon.

Round 3

Pick Player Owner
25 Rob Gronkowski (TE1) Chippin
26 Amari Cooper (WR11) Wilkins
27 Jerick McKinnon (RB15) Browne
28 Adam Thielen (WR12) Woods
29 Kenyan Drake (RB16) Holroyd
30 Christian McCaffrey (RB17) Bottero
31 Derrick Henry (RB18) Sanderson
32 Jay Ajayi (RB19) Boone
33 T.Y. Hilton (WR13) McLaren
34 Tyreek Hill (WR14) Alessandrini
35 Stefon Diggs (WR15) Tomlinson
36 Alshon Jeffery (WR16) Levine

Round 3: Being able to identify the talent in the third round will give fantasy owners a massive advantage this season. Gronk is an easy choice here, but there are plenty of landmines to navigate in the rest of the round ... Henry became one of those high-risk options when the Titans handed a significant contract to free agent Dion Lewis, a more dynamic weapon capable of handling lead back duties. At worst, Tennessee will be a committee, making Henry a tough sell in the third round ... Deciding between the Vikings' receivers might be a waste of time, since both are set up for strong fantasy campaigns with Kirk Cousins joining the team. Thielen gets a slight edge, but Diggs also carries low-end WR1 potential.

Round 4

Pick Player Owner
37 Travis Kelce (TE2) Levine
38 Mark Ingram (RB20) Tomlinson
39 Brandin Cooks (WR17) Alessandrini
40 Allen Robinson (WR18) McLaren
41 Sony Michel (RB21) Boone
42 Alex Collins (RB22) Sanderson
43 Aaron Rodgers (QB1) Bottero
44 Rashaad Penny (RB23) Holroyd
45 Derrius Guice (RB24) Woods
46 Demaryius Thomas (WR19) Browne
47 Josh Gordon (WR20) Wilkins
48 Larry Fitzgerald (WR21) Chippin

Round 4: Ingram, like most players facing a suspension, will be tricky to assess on draft day. He proved he can still be an RB1 even with Kamara breaking out in the same backfield last year, and once Ingram's in the lineup again, he should be a top-15 back. However, there's always the risk that he could lose his job or might not return as the same player. Saints fans remember what happened to Willie Snead in 2017. If you're looking to land Ingram, this is the range where you're going to have to take him, accepting all the possible outcomes ... Instead of Ingram, you're better off rolling the dice on one of the promising rookie backs like Michel, Penny, or Guice. Each will be counted on early and often for their new franchises and they offer league-winning potential if they hit.

Round 5

Pick Player Owner
49 Dion Lewis (RB25) Chippin
50 Aaron Jones (RB26) Wilkins
51 Chris Hogan (WR22) Browne
52 Zach Ertz (TE3) Woods
53 Golden Tate (WR23) Holroyd
54 Lamar Miller (RB27) Bottero
55 Greg Olsen (TE4) Sanderson
56 Marvin Jones (WR24) Boone
57 Ronald Jones II (RB28) McLaren
58 Marshawn Lynch (RB29) Alessandrini
59 Tevin Coleman (RB30) Tomlinson
60 Deshaun Watson (QB2) Levine

Round 5: If a timeshare does happen in Tennessee, taking Lewis at a two-round discount to Henry is the smarter play ... While there's upside in a wide-open Tampa Bay backfield, Jones is one rookie to shy away from. He doesn't profile as a sustaining rusher and the Bucs have already discussed keeping Peyton Barber involved ... If you feel like Hogan as the WR22 is a reach, take a closer look at his stats prior to his injury in 2017 ... Watson's historic on-pace stats prior to his torn ACL were enough to make him the QB2 in this draft, going ahead of Russell Wilson. I'd still lean toward Russ, who's proven himself as a top-five fantasy passer multiple times.

Round 6

Pick Player Owner
61 JuJu Smith-Schuster (WR25) Levine
62 Russell Wilson (QB3) Tomlinson
63 Jimmy Graham (TE5) Alessandrini
64 Marlon Mack (RB31) McLaren
65 Royce Freeman (RB32) Boone
66 Michael Crabtree (WR26) Sanderson
67 Devin Funchess (WR27) Bottero
68 Corey Davis (WR28) Holroyd
69 Julian Edelman (WR29) Woods
70 Tom Brady (QB4) Browne
71 Nick Chubb (RB33) Wilkins
72 Jarvis Landry (WR30) Chippin

Round 6: Quarterback is extremely deep, but getting Wilson in the sixth round is nice value ... Graham has the ability to win leagues if he makes an immediate red-zone connection with Rodgers. The only worry will be the 31-year-old's declining yardage totals. He's worth the gamble in the sixth or seventh round ... Mack, Freeman, and Chubb all have the opportunity to be lead backs this season if they can emerge from their respective backfield competitions. Of that trio, Freeman has the best chance to be the clear starter in Week 1.

Round 7

Pick Player Owner
73 Pierre Garcon (WR31) Chippin
74 Cam Newton (QB5) Wilkins
75 Kenny Stills (WR32) Browne
76 Robby Anderson (WR33) Woods
77 Carson Wentz (QB6) Holroyd
78 Emmanuel Sanders (WR34) Bottero
79 Robert Woods (WR35) Sanderson
80 D'Onta Foreman (RB34) Boone
81 Tarik Cohen (RB35) McLaren
82 Will Fuller (WR36) Alessandrini
83 Sammy Watkins (WR37) Tomlinson
84 Cooper Kupp (WR38) Levine

Round 7: At this point in the draft you should be swinging for the fences on players with immense upside ... It's nice to see Stills selected where he belongs, but based on his current ADP, you might be able to wait a round or two before pulling the trigger ... Cohen should get more work under offensive-minded new head coach Matt Nagy, though he's a better target in PPR leagues ... With Cooks joining the Rams' receiving corps, Kupp could have a hard time repeating his strong debut season. Even at the end of the seventh round, this seems like a reach.

Round 8

Pick Player Owner
85 Isaiah Crowell (RB36) Levine
86 Evan Engram (TE6) Tomlinson
87 Drew Brees (QB7) Alessandrini
88 C.J. Anderson (RB37) McLaren
89 Rex Burkhead (RB38) Boone
90 Randall Cobb (WR39) Sanderson
91 Kerryon Johnson (RB39) Bottero
92 Chris Thompson (RB40) Holroyd
93 Jamaal Williams (RB41) Woods
94 Delanie Walker (TE7) Browne
95 Josh Doctson (WR40) Wilkins
96 Carlos Hyde (RB42) Chippin

Round 8: If the Jets' offense can surprise us with another competent campaign, Crowell could be a steal in the eighth ... Team Sanderson's strategy to go zero-WR before the sixth round has yielded him a starting group of Crabtree, Woods, and Cobb. Regardless of what you think about his early RB selections, this is proof that waiting on receivers is a viable plan, and he still has opportunities to add some late-round lottery-tickets.

Round 9

Pick Player Owner
97 Devontae Booker (RB43) Chippin
98 Sterling Shepard (WR41) Wilkins
99 Matt Breida (RB44) Browne
100 Latavius Murray (RB45) Woods
101 Kyle Rudolph (TE8) Holroyd
102 Nelson Agholor (WR42) Bottero
103 Jordan Reed (TE9) Sanderson
104 Trey Burton (TE10) Boone
105 DeVante Parker (WR43) McLaren
106 Peyton Barber (RB46) Alessandrini
107 Bilal Powell (RB47) Tomlinson
108 Marqise Lee (WR44) Levine

Round 9: The season-ending injury to Hunter Henry means the drop-off at tight end occurs even earlier. Burton is a former backup who will get the chance to break out as the Bears' coaching staff plans to feature him. With the top-eight tight ends gone, and a realistic fear of being left empty-handed at the position, Burton was a necessary pick. Of the unproven commodities at tight end, he's the best bet to crack the top eight.

Round 10

Pick Player Owner
109 Jamison Crowder (WR45) Levine
110 DeSean Jackson (WR46) Tomlinson
111 Marquise Goodwin (WR47) Alessandrini
112 Martavis Bryant (WR48) McLaren
113 Kirk Cousins (QB8) Boone
114 Dez Bryant (WR49) Sanderson
115 Kelvin Benjamin (WR50) Bottero
116 Giovani Bernard (RB48) Holroyd
117 D.J. Moore (WR51) Woods
118 Mike Williams (WR52) Browne
119 Anthony Miller (WR53) Wilkins
120 Ben Roethlisberger (QB9) Chippin

Round 10: Cousins isn't an elite talent, but his consistency's tough to match as a top-seven fantasy QB in three straight seasons. In Minnesota, he'll get the best supporting cast of his career ... Team Sanderson snags Bryant as he continues to look for late-round upside at receiver. Bryant isn't the player he once was, but his value could increase significantly depending on his landing spot ... If Williams can stay on the field and carve out his role in the Chargers' offense, he'll rise up draft boards over the next few months.

Round 11

Pick Player Owner
121 Allen Hurns (WR54) Chippin
122 David Njoku (TE11) Wilkins
123 George Kittle (TE12) Browne
124 Matthew Stafford (QB10) Woods
125 Jordy Nelson (WR55) Holroyd
126 Chris Carson (RB49) Bottero
127 Philip Rivers (QB11) Sanderson
128 Duke Johnson (RB50) Boone
129 Matt Ryan (QB12) McLaren
130 Theo Riddick (RB51) Alessandrini
131 Spencer Ware (RB52) Tomlinson
132 Chris Godwin (WR56) Levine

Round 11: This is more proof for why you should wait on quarterback. It's much wiser to spend your 11th-round pick on perennial fantasy starters like Stafford or Rivers rather than investing in long shots at other positions ... Kittle and Njoku have breakout potential, but come with no guarantees. Drafting either as your TE1 will leave you exposed. If you're forced into that situation, make sure to pair them with another option to minimize the risk.

Round 12

Pick Player Owner
133 Andrew Luck (QB13) Levine
134 T.J. Yeldon (RB53) Tomlinson
135 Rishard Matthews (WR57) Alessandrini
136 Tyler Eifert (TE13) McLaren
137 Cameron Meredith (WR58) Boone
138 LeGarrette Blount (RB54) Sanderson
139 Jack Doyle (TE14) Bottero
140 Cameron Brate (TE15) Holroyd
141 Jameis Winston (QB14) Woods
142 Tyrell Williams (WR59) Browne
143 O.J. Howard (TE16) Wilkins
144 Patrick Mahomes (QB15) Chippin

Round 12: Luck and Mahomes might be the two most volatile fantasy quarterbacks this season, with their potential finishes ranging from top-five to outright cut from your team. They're best suited as high-upside backups for fantasy owners willing to carry two QBs ... Matthews, Meredith, and Williams could start the season as the No. 2 receiving options in prolific offenses. Keep an eye out for them in final rounds.

Mock Drafts

Daily Newsletter

Get the latest trending sports news daily in your inbox