Tarik Skubal is easily the top free agent this winter and could set a new MLB record for the richest contract signed by a pitcher. The two-time Cy Young winner is reportedly set to meet with at least six teams starting this week. Here, we make the case for why some of the league's biggest contenders should and shouldn't sign Skubal.
Atlanta Braves
Why they should: The Braves won 94 games last year despite having just one truly reliable starter in Chris Sale, and they can't depend on the injury-prone Spencer Strider, AJ Smith-Shawver, or Reynaldo López to contribute significantly in 2027. Grant Holmes also has to show he can take the next step. Even Sale, as great as he's been, will be entering his age-38 season. Skubal would give Atlanta long-term certainty atop the rotation while also reestablishing it as a top free-agent destination. With Skubal and Sale alongside a dynamic offense, the Braves would be poised to take control of the NL East next season.
Why they shouldn't: The Braves may have to look in the mirror and ask themselves, "How much do we trust our training staff?" As great as Skubal is, he missed time after elbow surgery last season and is about to turn 30. Given all of the team's pitching injuries over the last couple of years, it's fair to wonder if Atlanta is the right club for him from a health standpoint. Any organization investing this kind of money in a pitcher has to be confident it can keep him on the mound. Dollars could also factor into the decision regardless of what happens in CBA talks. The Braves have rarely, if ever, been a factor in the top tier of free agency, and they still have to re-sign some of their own over the next few seasons.
Chicago Cubs
Why they should: The Cubs just watched their division rival hoist a World Series trophy and their city rival make a deeper postseason run. Ever since breaking the curse, it's felt like ownership is fine with just filling Wrigley Field rather than obsessing over another title. Chicago hasn't produced a Cy Young finalist since Jon Lester in 2016, and it needs a true ace to lead the staff. Given their resources, there's no reason the Cubs shouldn't dominate the NL Central every year. Skubal is exactly the type of superstar pitcher Chicago needs.
Why they shouldn't: Jason Heyward's $184-million contract remains the franchise's richest pact. Despite playing in one of the biggest markets and being one of the sport's biggest brands, the Cubs' ownership clearly isn't comfortable handing out big-money deals and spending that much on one player. Chicago has plenty of payroll flexibility this winter, but it also needs to fill a lot of holes. With the club watching 60 homers and more than 120 starts head to free agency, you could argue that spreading that money around would be better.
Chicago White Sox
Why they should: This is the perfect time for the White Sox to strike in free agency. After three straight 100-loss seasons, the South Siders just finished a historic turnaround by making the playoffs, and they have a dynamic young core that's only getting better. Perhaps most importantly, they play in a massive media market where they've always been the little brother. Outbidding the Cubs for Skubal would change that instantly. He also fits the White Sox perfectly as the ace they desperately need to take that next step.
Why they shouldn't: There's no reason the White Sox shouldn't do this. Ultimately, it'll come down to whether or not they want to spend the money - and that's far from a guarantee. This franchise has never doled out a nine-figure contract (Andrew Benintendi's five-year, $75-million deal remains the largest in White Sox history), and the organization hasn't given any kind of indication that approach will change this winter. Longtime owner Jerry Reinsdorf sits on MLB's labor committee and has been a leading voice for a hard salary cap since the 1990s. No matter how much sense this makes on the field, it would be shocking if this were the moment Reinsdorf finally decided to splurge in free agency.
Los Angeles Dodgers
Why they should: Do we even have to explain this? It's the Dodgers. They find trillion-dollar bills underneath the couch in Andrew Friedman's suite. Affording Skubal's sky-high price tag won't be a problem, and he seemed to enjoy his time in Hollywood after the Dodgers acquired him in July. However, L.A. also has a legitimate baseball reason to do this: the team has continued to struggle to find consistent starting pitching behind Yoshinobu Yamamoto. The Dodgers can't go into next season assuming Shohei Ohtani, Blake Snell, and Tyler Glasnow, among other injury-plagued starters, will be yearlong contributors. Skubal is the rotation stabilizer they need.
Why they shouldn't: The Dodgers might be overflowing with money for years to come, but can they really afford to hitch their wagon to another expensive pitcher who's about to hit the wrong side of 30? Although Skubal has two Cy Youngs and is one of the top five pitchers in baseball, he also missed time last season after having loose bodies removed from his elbow - the same procedure that Snell and Edwin Díaz underwent this past campaign. The Dodgers are great, but they're aging, vulnerable, and have a poor track record of keeping pitchers healthy. They have good reason to be careful.
New York Mets
Why they should: When you have the richest owner in the sport, you shouldn't overlook any star player. The Mets missed the playoffs in back-to-back seasons and are coming off their worst year since 2020. A major contributor to New York's struggles was a rotation that ranked 22nd in innings pitched and 23rd in ERA. Skubal would give the club an ace and something of a mentor for young pitchers Nolan McLean and Christian Scott. Despite their struggles last season, the Mets aren't far from being a playoff contender again, and Skubal would only affirm that.
Why they shouldn't: The Mets have no real reason not to go all-in on Skubal. Even with the threat of a salary cap looming, the team has more than $62 million coming off the books next winter from the contracts of Sean Manaea, Jorge Polanco, and Kodai Senga. If Skubal doesn't land in Queens, it feels like it'll be his choice and not the Mets'.
New York Yankees
Why they should: The Yankees haven't won a World Series since 2009, and that should be driving Brian Cashman and Hal Steinbrenner nuts. Pairing Skubal with Cam Schlittler atop the rotation would give New York the best 1-2 punch in the majors, with Gerrit Cole, Max Fried, and Carlos Rodón rounding out a wildly deep rotation. However, any Skubal deal could mean Cashman uses the team's surplus of starting pitching to address needs elsewhere. With Cole and Rodón signed for only two more seasons, adding Skubal would give the team more long-term stability.
Why they shouldn't: Schlitter's emergence as an ace helps negate the need for Skubal, and the Yankees have a considerable amount of money ($91 million) committed to Cole, Fried, and Rodón next season. Sure, New York hasn't won a World Series in ages, but pitching hasn't been the biggest issue behind the drought. Cashman needs to focus on building an offense that can win in October. Plus, it would be counterintuitive for Steinbrenner to preach the need for a salary cap and then sign Skubal.
San Diego Padres
Why they should: Have you seen their current rotation? Michael King, Walker Buehler, Griffin Canning, Nick Pivetta, Robbie Ray, Casey Mize, and Lucas Giolito are all free agents, leaving a projected group of starters who threw 207 combined innings in the majors last season. You could argue that no team on this list needs Skubal as much as San Diego. After trying to patch things up on the fly in recent years, there's no better way for new ownership to announce their presence than by luring the top free agent away from the Dodgers. And you know Skubal's personality would mesh well with one of baseball's most fiery teams.
Why they shouldn't: The Padres already have a projected CBT payroll of $222 million. With so many holes across the roster, spreading that money over the rotation and beefing up the lineup's depth is likely a better way to stay competitive. San Diego could potentially land two impact starters for Skubal's price. The Padres also have significant money committed to Manny Machado, Xander Bogaerts, and Fernando Tatis Jr. through at least 2033, so it's somewhat defensible if ownership doesn't want to add another massive long-term contract.
Toronto Blue Jays
Why they should: The Blue Jays are motivated to spend again after a last-place finish, and ownership has shown it has the means to compete with any big market. Toronto's offense needs the most help, but that shouldn't push top-tier pitching down the shopping list. Pairing Skubal with AL Cy Young runner-up Dylan Cease would give them a formidable duo and add certainty to a rotation that struggled to stay healthy this past season.
Why they shouldn't: Offense really held the Blue Jays back in 2026, finishing last in the majors in homers and runs scored. Toronto needs to spend considerable resources fixing the lineup, and that should be the focus. While the position-player free-agent class is extremely thin, the same can't be said about the starting pitcher market. Even without Skubal, the Blue Jays can still land at least one difference-maker in the rotation, likely at a fraction of Skubal's cost. Toronto also has a strong track record of unlocking the potential of several pitchers in recent years and could look to get more value out of an arm the team has identified at a lower cost.













