Though we're only about two weeks into the 2026-27 college basketball season, an unusually high number of marquee matchups to start the campaign has already given us a lot to evaluate.
Combine that with a tumultuous offseason marked by lawsuits and eligibility concerns, and you get a level of intrigue and uncertainty that puts college basketball in a unique position.
Let's look at some of the most notable storylines and results from the early season and break down what they could mean for the rest of the year.
Serious concerns for Duke
Just two weeks ago, Duke was a consensus top-two team in the country. Now, after falling 79-73 to Michigan State and then suffering a more embarrassing 99-78 home loss to Illinois, the Blue Devils have already matched last year's regular-season loss total. Their struggles have exposed concerns across the board.
For one, Duke doesn't have a true star. After having the best player in the sport in back-to-back years in Cooper Flagg and Cameron Boozer, the Blue Devils aren't rostering a single player who's in the top 500 in shot usage and lack a lead option they can rely on for a late-game bucket. Hopes were high that 17-year-old freshman Joaquim Boumtje Boumtje could be that player, but he hasn't found his jumper yet.

To that end, the team-wide shooting has been atrocious, with Duke making just 28.2% of threes and only senior guard Caleb Foster shooting over 30% on more than 10 total attempts. Wisconsin transfer John Blackwell was supposed to help with spacing, but he's just 10-for-35 from beyond the arc so far.
The Blue Devils' defense hasn't been at its best, either. Playing Boumtje Boumtje and fellow big man Patrick Ngongba together has hurt Duke's overall defensive mobility, and the team has few reliable perimeter defenders outside of Dame Sarr and Sebastian Wilkins, who can't really play together because of the lack of spacing. The issues with this group are piling up, and they go far beyond just poor performances.
Value of 5th years
The drama surrounding the NCAA's switch to a five-in-five eligibility model, the exclusion of the 2022 high school class from that change, and the subsequent lawsuits were a hot-button topic throughout the offseason. In last Saturday's game between LSU and Gonzaga, the realities of those battles were on full display.
Seven of the Bulldogs' 14 assists came from guards Xaivian Lee and Javon Bennett, who both received a fifth year of eligibility from the courts. Additionally, stretch forward Chauncey Wiggins made his first appearance for Gonzaga after being ruled eligible just days earlier.
But the Tigers' fifth-year duo of Donovan Dent and Skyy Clark stole the show, scoring 37 points and adding 11 assists. Dent capped the performance by hitting a last-second 3-pointer to seal LSU's win. Without the eligibility lawsuits, this game would've been completely different on both sides. Whether you agree with the legal fight or not, its impact on college basketball is undeniable.
The effect extends beyond those two programs. Kansas' Tre White and Melvin Council; Texas Tech's Darrion Williams, Donovan Atwell, and Jamichael Stillwell; and Iowa State's Tamin Lipsey have all significantly contributed to top teams.
Houston takes down Florida in early Game of the Year
After watching Duke go down with ease on Tuesday, No. 1 Florida had a chance to stake its claim as the undisputed top team. Instead, the Gators were outscored by 13 points in the second half and lost to No. 8 Houston.
However, all the warning signs were there: Florida fell to Baylor in the preseason, had ups and downs against Miami and Florida State, and showed a concerning lack of depth in stretches against quality competition. Against the Cougars, the Gators' bench scored just two points, excluding Urban Klavzar.
That said, discussing Florida's shortcomings shouldn't take away from Houston's excellent play. After losing Kingston Flemings to the NBA draft in June, the Cougars clearly have a new star point guard in Dedan Thomas Jr. Along with defensive ace JoJo Tugler, the team combines head coach Kelvin Sampson's defensive identity and rebounding emphasis with plenty of complementary scoring.
If there's one thing we've learned over the past two weeks, it's that Duke and Florida may not be the clear top teams that many expected at the start of the campaign.
Feshman drop-off
Last season featured one of the best freshman classes ever. With nearly all those superstars off to the NBA, fifth-year players taking more roster spots, and a relatively weak high school class, freshman production has dropped off sharply this campaign.
Case in point: Four of the top six KenPom Player of the Year scores went to first-year players in 2025-26. This season, none are in the top 10. Missouri's Jason Crowe Jr. is also the only power-conference freshman averaging at least 18 points per game, down from eight freshmen from major conferences who reached the mark last season. The gap particularly stands out because players on power-conference teams often boost their counting stats against lower-level opponents at this time of year.

Obviously, things can change as the season progresses and these young players grow more comfortable. Top high school recruits Tyran Stokes (Kansas) and Jordan Smith Jr. (Arkansas) have shown flashes but have struggled to shoot efficiently. Boumtje Boumtje and UCLA's Nikola Kusturica, meanwhile, should become superstars in time. Even so, the past two weeks have shown us that last season's freshman stardom won't be replicated.
Early returns on new coaches
Four power-conference head coaches led their teams to last year's NCAA Tournament in their first season at the helm. The transfer portal and other roster-reshaping tools now give new staffs a faster path to turning a program around.
This season, Michigan's Mike Boynton, LSU's Will Wade, Cincinnati's Jerrod Calhoun, Utah State's Ben Jacobson, and Providence's Bryan Hodgson all have their teams in KenPom's top 50. While coaches like Boynton and Jacobson retained key pieces from previous regimes, a handful of those bench bosses had to start from scratch.

Coaches taking over for program legends are off to strong starts, too. Saint Mary's, led by Mickey McConnell, is currently ahead of former Gaels coach Randy Bennett and Arizona State in KenPom. Creighton has also impressed, earning an impressive win over Iowa and posting a 3-1 record under Alan Huss, who took over for the now-retired Greg McDermott.
The coaching cycle is always a major storyline throughout the offseason, so it'll be interesting to follow the new hires and see if they can sustain their early success.
Matthew Winick is a college basketball analyst and consultant. You can find his work on X at @matthewwinick.












