Split decisions: Is Usman-Masvidal the right fight?

ABU DHABI, UNITED ARAB EMIRATES - JULY 12: (R-L) Jorge Masvidal punches Kamaru Usman of Nigeria in their UFC welterweight championship fight during the UFC 251 event at Flash Forum on UFC Fight Island on July 12, 2020 on Yas Island, Abu Dhabi, United Arab Emirates.
Jeff Bottari / UFC / Getty

In "Split decisions," theScore's Nick Baldwin weighs in on the hottest topics in mixed martial arts.

This week, the UFC announced the rematch between Kamaru Usman and Jorge Masvidal will headline UFC 261 on April 24; Paulo Costa reportedly withdrew from the April 17 main event against Robert Whittaker due to an illness; it was reported that a lightweight bout between Tony Ferguson and Beneil Dariush is in the works for UFC 262 on May 15.

Let's discuss.

Was a rematch between Usman and Masvidal the right fight to make?

Jeff Bottari / UFC / Getty

From a business standpoint, this was the UFC's best option. Masvidal is still one of the most popular fighters in the sport, so him challenging for the welterweight title will draw more eyes than any other contender. Plus, there's real beef between Usman and Masvidal. Their first fight last July was one of 2020's best-selling pay-per-view cards, and the rematch will likely be another box office success.

But from a sporting standpoint, a Usman-Masvidal rematch was not the fight to make. The first fight wasn't entertaining; Usman controlled Masvidal for the better part of five rounds. It's been his least exciting title defense so far. And it's tough to see a path to victory for Masvidal.

More importantly, Masvidal hasn't stepped into the Octagon since. Even though the division doesn't have a clear-cut No. 1 contender, "Gamebred" should've had to pick up at least one win before re-entering the title conversation. A rematch between Usman and Colby Covington would've been a better option, since their first meeting was a "Fight of the Year" candidate and Covington has earned a win since losing to Usman in 2019.

The best argument in favor of Masvidal is that he took the first fight on six days' notice. Masvidal didn't perform to the best of his ability because he had almost no time to get ready for Usman. He should have a better performance now that he has over a month to prepare.

But he didn't have to fill in for Gilbert Burns. That was his decision, and he lost to Usman - who also agreed to face Masvidal on six days' notice - fair and square. It was a well-deserved opportunity at the time, but he certainly didn't earn this rematch. Since when has someone been rewarded with a title shot for sitting on the sidelines?

Is Ferguson-Dariush good matchmaking?

Jeff Bottari / UFC / Getty

Ferguson-Dariush is not just good matchmaking, it's perfect matchmaking. Ferguson needed a step down in competition and Dariush needed a step up. This contest fits the bill for both fighters.

The two lightweights are on completely different career trajectories. Former interim champ Ferguson is riding the first losing streak of his 30-fight career, while Dariush has won six in a row and is looking to cement himself among the elite at 155 pounds.

Ferguson is coming off losses to Justin Gaethje and Charles Oliveira, two of the top lightweights on the planet. Dariush is, at least on paper, a more winnable matchup for him, so we'll get to see exactly how much "El Cucuy" has left in the tank. Meanwhile, Dariush bested the No. 12-ranked Diego Ferreira in his last outing and deserves to face a big name.

The stakes will be high when Ferguson and Dariush collide - there isn't room for both men at the top of the division. Either Ferguson will bounce back and defend his top-five spot or Dariush will ascend to contention.

Who could step in against Whittaker?

Handout / Getty Images Sport / Getty

Editor's note: This article was published before Kelvin Gastelum was announced as Paulo Costa's replacement.

My first thought is if Kevin Holland beats Derek Brunson in Saturday's main event and walks away unscathed, he'll absolutely call for the Whittaker fight and be the front-runner to replace Costa. In 2020, "Trailblazer" became the third fighter in modern UFC history to go 5-0 in a calendar year, and he's no stranger to fights on short notice. Whittaker is a former champ and ranked No. 1 in the division, so this would be a huge opportunity for Holland, a rising star who's ranked No. 10.

Another possibility would be rebooking Whittaker against Kelvin Gastelum. They were supposed to square off for the undisputed title in early 2019 and it was shaping up to be a great matchup. But Whittaker, the middleweight champion at the time, withdrew on the day of the event due to a hernia. The fight never materialized after that since Gastelum lost to Israel Adesanya in an interim-title bout two months later. Gastelum recently expressed interest in stepping in against Whittaker or Costa if one of them pulled out, so this may be the most viable option.

It's also worth mentioning that another marquee middleweight tilt between Darren Till and Marvin Vettori is scheduled for the April 10 main event. If one of them happens to get hurt in the next week or so, it's possible the other fighter will get slotted in against Whittaker. But that would likely only happen if Holland and Gastelum are both unavailable.

XRedditFacebookWhatsAppEmailSMS

More Stories