Skip to content

MLB Positional Fantasy Rankings: Outfield (Part 3)

Brace Hemmelgarn / Getty Images Sport / Getty

Here are theScore's 2016 fantasy outfielder rankings (click here for Part 1 and here for Part 2; projections provided by Steamer (via Fangraphs) and theScore staff):

Positional Rankings
C | 1B | 2B | 3B | SS | OF1 | OF2 | OF3 | DH | SP1 | SP2 | SP3 | RP

51. Steven Souza, Tampa Bay Rays

SEASON HR R RBI SB AVG.
2014 2 2 2 0 .130
2015 16 58 40 12 .225
2016 (PROJ.) 20 63 67 15 .240

Souza possesses both power and speed, so optimistic fantasy owners can look for 20-20 potential. That ceiling puts him in the conversation in rounds 22-24 of a mixed league. However, he struck out 33.8% of the time and dealt with hand injuries in the second half of the season. For a closing round pick in mixed leagues, the ceiling is high and the floor is low.

52. Wil Myers, San Diego Padres

SEASON HR R RBI SB AVG.
2014 6 37 35 6 .222
2015 8 40 29 5 .253
2016 (PROJ.) 20 72 73 10 .266

Myers has great potential to contribute in all five categories. However, injuries have always derailed his ability to stay on the field, and the same can be expected in 2016. His power makes him an OF4 with upside in mixed leagues who can be drafted between rounds 18-24.

53. Stephen Piscotty, St. Louis Cardinals

SEASON HR R RBI SB AVG
2014 -- -- -- -- --
2015 7 29 39 2 .305
2016 (PROJ.) 14 65 68 7 .273

Piscotty is unlikely to provide the power you want from an outfielder, but offers modest contributions in every category except steals. Don't expect a .305 average again, but he should still boast a solid average. Draft him between rounds 16-20 in mixed leagues as an OF4 or backup 1B.

54. Chris Colabello, Toronto Blue Jays

SEASON HR R RBI SB AVG
2014 6 17 39 0 .229
2015 15 55 54 2 .321
2016 (PROJ.) 20 61 73 3 .277

Colabello's value is hampered by his platoon with Justin Smoak. If he earns an everyday role, his value would take a significant jump. Going into 2016, he is worth selecting in the middle rounds of an AL-only league. His .421 BABIP and .321 average from 2015 are unsustainable, so don't get too enthralled by last season's counting numbers.

55. Delino DeShields. Texas Rangers

SEASON HR R RBI SB AVG.
2014 -- -- -- -- --
2015 2 83 37 25 .261
2016 (PROJ.) 8 77 50 33 .262

DeShields will be the leadoff man for Texas, putting him in a position to do damage on the bases; the Rangers finished third in runs scored last year (751). Expect him to eclipse the 30-steal mark this year. Draft-wise, DeShields is a speed-reliant OF4/5 going in rounds 22-24 in mixed leagues.

56. Matt Holliday, St. Louis Cardinals

SEASON HR R RBI SB AVG.
2014 20 83 90 4 .272
2015 4 24 35 2 .279
2016 (PROJ.) 15 67 68 2 .278

Holliday's home run totals had been decreasing since 2013, and they fell off a cliff in 2015. However, that can be attributed to him only playing 73 games last year because of injury. If you can handle the age (37) and injury threat, Holliday is a buy-low candidate after the top 40 outfielders are selected. Expect some bounce back simply with better health.

57. Denard Span, San Francisco Giants

SEASON HR R RBI SB AVG.
2014 5 94 37 31 .302
2015 5 38 22 11 .301
2016 (PROJ.) 4 70 41 20 .285

Span may be the poor man's Ben Revere, as he provides runs, steals, and a respectable average. Revere has an ADP of 108, while Span's sits at 274. Span only played 61 games due to injury, so his market value is far below where he should finish with a healthy 2016. Draft him outside the top 40 as an OF5 in mixed leagues and an OF3 in NL-only.

58. Domingo Santana, Milwaukee Brewers

SEASON HR R RBI SB AVG.
2014 0 1 0 0 .000
2015 8 20 26 4 .238
2016 (PROJ.) 20 65 70 8 .245

The departure of Khris Davis will open up playing time for Santana, whose bat should excel in Miller Park. Unfortunately, his power also came with a 33.7% strikeout rate in 2015. If he secures an everyday position, Santana can likely be found in the final four rounds of a mixed league if you still desire power at the expense of average.

59. Marcell Ozuna, Miami Marlins

SEASON HR R RBI SB AVG.
2014 23 72 85 3 .269
2015 10 47 44 2 .259
2016 (PROJ.) 17 60 72 3 .267

Ozuna is a sleeper this season after a disappointing 2015 saw him spend time in the minors. However, he did hit 23 homers in 2014, so the power is there to warrant a 22nd-to-24th-round pick in mixed leagues. Late-round power like that is rare, but it comes with volatility. He's a bench option in mixed leagues.

60. Byron Buxton, Minnesota Twins

SEASON HR R RBI SB AVG.
2014 -- -- -- -- --
2015 2 16 6 2 .209
2016 (PROJ.) 10 51 52 22 .260

Buxton is one of the game's top prospects, but he struggled with a 31.9% strikeout rate in 2015. Going into 2016, his potential makes him worth drafting in rounds 15-18 of mixed leagues as an OF4 as long as your top three are locked in.

61. Kevin Kiermaier, Tampa Bay Rays

SEASON HR R RBI SB AVG.
2014 10 35 35 5 .263
2015 10 62 40 18 .263
2016 (PROJ.) 11 60 61 17 .265

Kiermaier fails to complement his proficiency on the bases with respectable power. Going into 2016, it seems unlikely he pairs the two together for a breakout year. He represents more of a "safe floor" than a "high ceiling" gamble at the back end of mixed leagues. In AL-only leagues, he's a solid if unspectacular OF3.

62. Melky Cabrera, Chicago White Sox

SEASON HR R RBI SB AVG.
2014 16 81 73 6 .301
2015 12 70 77 3 .273
2016 (PROJ.) 12 71 62 3 .279

Cabrera is now a non-factor in terms of steals, and that significantly hurts his fantasy value. Batting in front of Todd Frazier and Jose Abreu helps his prospects, but fantasy owners can likely find better value elsewhere. He is an OF3 in AL-only leagues that should be drafted in the middle rounds.

▲63. Odubel Herrera, Philadelphia Phillies

SEASON HR R RBI SB AVG
2014 -- -- -- -- --
2015 8 64 41 16 .297
2016 (PROJ.) 8 70 50 16 .277

Herrera turned into an absolute steal for the Phillies and the fantasy owners who picked him up off waivers in 2015. However, there are concerns over his high BABIP (.387), strikeout rate (24%), and low walk rate (5.2%). Consensus on Herrera seems to be mixed, so reserve him for NL-only leagues in the second half of the draft. He has had a productive spring though if it is worth anything.

64. Danny Valencia, Oakland Athletics

SEASON HR R RBI SB AVG.
2014 4 20 30 1 .258
2015 18 59 66 2 .290
2016 (PROJ.) 14 54 60 3 .265

Valencia is coming off a career year, so some regression is expected. In 2015, Valencia showed vast improvement against righties, hitting for 13 homers and a .285 average. Prior to that, his best season in those respects came in 2011, with 11 homers and a .224 average. Ultimately, Valencia is at best a late-round flier in mixed leagues.

65. Yasmany Tomas, Arizona Diamondbacks

SEASON HR R RBI SB AVG
2014 -- -- -- -- --
2015 9 40 48 5 .273
2016 (PROJ.) 17 53 65 9 .264

Tomas under-delivered last year after promises of big time power. Fantasy owners will likely be wary of Tomas and reserve him for NL-only leagues. That's a fair assessment going into 2016, as some reports suggest his starting role is not entirely set in stone. In NL-only leagues, he is an OF3 who should be drafted in the middle rounds.

66. Rusney Castillo, Boston Red Sox

SEASON HR R RBI SB AVG
2014 2 6 6 3 .333
2015 5 35 29 4 .253
2016 (PROJ.) 10 45 47 10 .268

Castillo looks to be an everyday player for the Red Sox, which puts double-digit home run and steal totals in play. His poor 2015 has many writing him off as a bust, which could still prove to be true. But as an OF4 available in the middle rounds of AL-only drafts, he may be worth the risk.

67. Carlos Beltran, New York Yankees

SEASON HR R RBI SB AVG
2014 15 46 49 3 .233
2015 19 57 67 0 .276
2016 (PROJ.) 14 51 55 0 .266

Beltran had a respectable 2015 but may lose playing time to Yankees prospect Aaron Hicks in 2016. At 39, Beltran is far past his prime. Pass on him in mixed leagues and scoop him up as an OF4 in AL-only leagues between rounds 16-18.

68. Brandon Moss, St. Louis Cardinals

SEASON HR R RBI SB AVG
2014 25 70 81 1 .234
2015 19 47 58 0 .226
2016 (PROJ.) 18 55 60 0 .244

Moss is likely to be platooned, as he offers home run power against right-handers only. With that in mind, he does not offer consistency, but can serve as a bench player if you are willing and able to move him in and out of your lineup. He is unlikely to be drafted in mixed leagues, reserving his value to backup 1B/OF duties in NL-only formats.

69. Nick Markakis, Atlanta Braves

SEASON HR R RBI SB AVG
2014 14 81 50 4 .276
2015 3 73 53 2 .296
2016 (PROJ.) 9 70 57 2 .277

Markakis makes for a decent addition to a fantasy bench if you can live without steals and homers. With an OBP likely around .350 and a lineup spot ahead of Freddie Freeman, he should score 70-80 times. An average between .275-.290 is also within reach. He is an OF4 in NL-only leagues with some value appeal in rounds 16-20.

▼70. Jayson Werth, Washington Nationals

SEASON HR R RBI SB AVG
2014 16 85 82 9 .292
2015 12 51 42 0 .221
2016 (PROJ.) 10 49 52 1 .272

Werth will turn 37 this season and only played in 88 games last year due to a broken wrist. But the emergence of Washington prospect Michael Taylor is legitimate threat to his playing time. Werth can offer home runs at a discounted rate for NL-only leagues in rounds 14-17.

▲71. Marlon Byrd, Cleveland Indians

SEASON HR R RBI SB AVG
2014 25 71 85 3 .264
2015 23 58 73 2 .247
2016 (PROJ.) 15 50 51 2 .248

Approaching 39 years old, Byrd stays relevant through his power. He has hit over 20 homers each of the past three years, which is valuable in both real and fantasy baseball. His new place of employment makes him slightly more valuable due to the absences of Michael Brantley, Lonnie Chisenhall, and Abraham Almonte but only for a short time. He is a final-round selection in AL-only leagues with the potential of 20-homer upside.

▲72. Leonys Martin, Seattle Mariners

SEASON HR R RBI SB AVG
2014 7 68 40 31 .274
2015 5 26 25 14 .219
2016 (PROJ.) 6 45 47 22 .255

Martin was moved to Seattle after losing his job in center field last year in Texas. He should see more at-bats and a full-time role, but with a place at the bottom of the order. His main fantasy appeal is his speed, which could result in 25-30 stolen bases. Draft him in the closing rounds of an AL-only if you want speed.

73. Nori Aoki, Seattle Mariners

SEASON HR R RBI SB AVG
2014 1 63 43 17 .285
2015 5 42 26 14 .287
2016 (PROJ.) 5 65 42 15 .280

Aoki will likely bat leadoff for the Mariners, giving him the potential to score 70+ runs. However, his lack of power and modest steal count does not make him much of a fantasy option. He is not in the discussion for mixed leagues, but comes into play as an OF4/5 in AL-only. If you're looking for upside though, risk a flier on a power bat instead of Aoki.

74. Rajai Davis, Cleveland Indians

SEASON HR R RBI SB AVG
2014 8 64 51 36 .282
2015 8 55 30 18 .258
2016 (PROJ.) 7 45 43 22 .260

Davis' 2016 production will ultimately depend on his role with the Indians and whether Cleveland finds him a platoon partner. If he bats alone in the leadoff spot, Davis will make for a great bargain play in AL-only formats. Draft him between rounds 20-24 for steals and take any upside that falls your way.

▼75. Cameron Maybin, Detroit Tigers

SEASON HR R RBI SB AVG
2014 1 24 15 4 .235
2015 10 65 59 23 .267
2016 (PROJ.) 8 50 37 19 .260

Maybin is likely to miss all of April due to a hairline fracture suffered in early May. An OF4/5 in AL-only formats, Maybin provides speed on the bases and nothing else. His role on the Tigers is also not entirely clear as he may form a platoon with Anthony Gose, subsequently limiting his plate appearances. Maybin should be available in rounds 18-20.

Daily Newsletter

Get the latest trending sports news daily in your inbox