Skip to content

MLB Positional Fantasy Rankings: Second Base

Troy Taormina-USA TODAY Sports

Here are theScore's 2016 fantasy second baseman rankings (projections provided by Steamer (via Fangraphs) and theScore staff):

Positional Rankings
C | 1B | 2B | 3B | SS | OF1 | OF2 | OF3 | DH | SP1 | SP2 | SP3 | RP

1. Jose Altuve, Houston Astros

SEASON HR R RBI SB AVG
2014 7 85 59 56 .341
2015 15 86 66 38 .313
2016 (PROJ.) 12 102 68 32 .316

Altuve suffered a decline from 2014's outstanding 56 stolen bases, but his production was elite in the other categories for a fourth consecutive year. His 15 home runs from last season aren't likely to be duplicated, but there are plenty of runs to be scored in Houston's lineup. He's the best at a premium position, and deserving of a selection late in the first round.

2. Robinson Cano, Seattle Mariners

SEASON HR R RBI SB AVG
2014 14 77 82 10 .314
2015 21 82 79 2 .287
2016 (PROJ.) 26 85 87 8 .293

Cano's second half of 2015 was the best showing in his two years with the Mariners. He hit 15 home runs in 70 games, showing the 30-home run potential he had with the New York Yankees. The days of elite upside are finished, but he provides a high floor as a second-round selection.

3. Brian Dozier, Minnesota Twins

SEASON HR R RBI SB AVG
2014 23 112 71 21 .242
2015 28 101 77 12 .236
2016 (PROJ.) 26 96 84 17 .257

Dozier compensates for a poor batting average with consistently high home run totals and a sufficient number of stolen bases. He'll bat in the heart of the most dangerous lineup the Twins have had during his five-year career. While his high strikeout rate is damaging, an improved BABIP should bring a more respectable average. He's a bargain at a sixth-round ADP.

4. Matt Carpenter, St. Louis Cardinals

SEASON HR R RBI SB AVG
2014 8 99 59 5 .272
2015 28 101 84 4 .272
2016 (PROJ.) 18 113 82 6 .281

Carpenter's 28 home runs from 2015 won't be repeated. While hitting at the top of the Cardinals' lineup, the opportunities for runs and RBIs represent his best fantasy contributions. He'll have a high batting average for someone with his power potential, but last season's .233 ISO will drop significantly.

5. Dee Gordon, Miami Marlins

SEASON HR R RBI SB AVG
2014 2 92 34 64 .289
2015 4 88 46 58 .333
2016 (PROJ.) 2 96 44 46 .284

Gordon's stellar batting average last season was a direct result of his otherworldly .383 BABIP. A more conventional average in 2016 would mean fewer opportunities for stolen bases. A full season from OF Giancarlo Stanton will lead to more runs scored, but he won't have many RBI opportunities while leading off. He's a major risk as a third-round pick.

6. Ian Kinsler, Detroit Tigers

SEASON HR R RBI SB AVG
2014 17 100 92 15 .275
2015 11 94 73 10 .296
2016 (PROJ.) 16 98 64 13 .290

Both Kinsler's power and speed have been declining for several seasons now, but he continues getting on base and scoring runs. The addition of OF Justin Upton to the Tigers' lineup provides insurance behind Kinsler, but he'll struggle to drive in runs as the lineup turns over from a weak bottom third.

7. Anthony Rendon, Washington Nationals

SEASON HR R RBI SB AVG
2014 21 111 83 17 .287
2015 5 43 25 1 .264
2016 (PROJ.) 17 92 70 12 .283

Rendon enters 2016 with plenty of risk and intrigue after being held to just 80 games last year. He likely overperformed in 2014, but does offer a well-round stat sheet. He has an appealing spot in the batting order, with OF Bryce Harper hitting in the same third of the lineup. He's a safe pick in the middle rounds of drafts, as he comes with an injury discount.

8. Kolten Wong, St. Louis Cardinals

SEASON HR R RBI SB AVG
2014 12 52 42 20 .249
2015 11 71 61 15 .262
2016 (PROJ.) 14 81 76 23 .258

Wong will need to show major improvement against left-handed pitching in order to maintain an everyday spot in the lineup. He will face enough righties to amass a respectable home run total. While his average is somewhat lackluster, the Cardinals may ask him to steal more often while at the bottom of the lineup.

9. Ben Zobrist, Chicago Cubs

SEASON HR R RBI SB AVG
2014 10 83 52 10 .272
2015 13 76 56 3 .276
2016 (PROJ.) 15 88 72 7 .281

After splitting 2015 with the Oakland Athletics and Kansas City Royals, Zobrist joins the most dangerous batting order he's ever been in. He'll both score and drive in runs while in the top third of the Cubs' lineup. He'll offer modest home run and steal numbers. He's a very safe - though not flash flashy - selection in the later middle rounds.

10. Addison Russell, Chicago Cubs

SEASON HR R RBI SB AVG
2014 -- -- -- -- --
2015 13 60 54 4 .242
2016 (PROJ.) 17 70 73 10 .271

Dual eligibility at second base and shortstop adds to Russell's overall fantasy value. Russell hasn't demonstrated elite speed, but he did steal 21 bases at Class-High A in 2013. He'll score runs from the bottom of the Cubs' lineup, and he's a good value pick in the middle rounds of standard mixed drafts.

▲11. Jonathan Schoop, Baltimore Orioles

SEASON HR R RBI SB AVG
2014 16 48 45 2 .209
2015 15 34 39 2 .279
2016 (PROJ.) 26 67 78 5 .261

Schoop should receive regular playing time at the major-league level in 2016, and 30 home runs can't be ruled out at this point. He took a major step with his batting average in 2015, though his .329 BABIP may regress. He's available in the final rounds of 12-team drafts, but his power could bring mid-round returns.

12. Rougned Odor, Texas Rangers

SEASON HR R RBI SB AVG
2014 9 39 48 4 .259
2015 16 54 61 6 .261
2016 (PROJ.) 15 73 68 15 .268

Odor looked the part of a top-tier fantasy second baseman late in 2015, showing major improvements at the plate following a mid-season demotion to Triple-A. He projects to start the season near the bottom of the batting order, but he should be able to work his way up with early-season success.

13. DJ LeMahieu, Colorado Rockies

SEASON HR R RBI SB AVG
2014 5 59 42 10 .267
2015 6 85 61 23 .301
2016 (PROJ.) 8 77 65 24 .294

LeMahieu broke out with 23 stolen bases in 2015. He'll likely need to do more running in 2016, with SS Troy Tulowitzki and OF Corey Dickerson - and potentially SS Jose Reyes - no longer in Colorado. His average will regress, but he's an excellent late-round option at second base or middle infield.

14. Jason Kipnis, Cleveland Indians

SEASON HR R RBI SB AVG
2014 6 61 41 22 .240
2015 9 86 52 12 .303
2016 (PROJ.) 7 81 61 11 .269

Both power and speed have been dwindling for Kipnis, though he still gets on base. The Indians' offense should be improved in 2016, providing opportunities for Kipnis to score runs while near the top of the lineup. He offers safety, though a lowered ceiling makes him somewhat unattractive with an early-round ADP.

15. Starlin Castro, New York Yankees

SEASON HR R RBI SB AVG
2014 14 58 65 4 .292
2015 11 52 69 5 .265
2016 (PROJ.) 13 68 73 13 .285

The Yankees and fantasy owners alike are hoping a change of scenery will lead to a bounce-back performance for Castro. As a right-handed hitter, he'll miss out on the all-important right-field short porch at Yankees Stadium. Even with meager home run offerings, he'll return value at an all-time low ADP.

16. Dustin Pedroia, Boston Red Sox

SEASON HR R RBI SB AVG
2014 7 72 53 6 .278
2015 12 46 42 2 .291
2016 (PROJ.) 10 64 57 8 .292

Pedroia's power resurfaced in 2015, and he would've pushed 20 home runs had he been healthy all year. He was a non-factor on the basepaths, with his two steals representing a career low. He's going late enough to be used as a middle infielder as opposed to a starting second baseman. He's a good option in Round 15 or later.

17. Josh Harrison, Pittsburgh Pirates

SEASON HR R RBI SB AVG
2014 13 77 52 18 .315
2015 4 57 28 10 .287
2016 (PROJ.) 11 76 55 14 .282

Harrison's positional versatility is a nice bonus, but he's better suited for a middle-infield spot in lineups, or as a backup second baseman. His true abilities lie somewhere in the middle of the past two seasons, and he's an excellent sleeper option in the latter rounds of drafts with owners scared off by last year.

18. Matt Duffy, San Francisco Giants

SEASON HR R RBI SB AVG
2014 0 5 8 0 .267
2015 12 77 77 12 .295
2016 (PROJ.) 14 72 73 15 .290

Duffy is unlikely to improve too much on last year's power numbers, but he did show base stealing promise in several levels of the minor leagues, so an increase in SBs is possible. He has maintained a consistently high BABIP over most levels, leading to an impressive batting average. He's a capable backup infielder in mixed leagues. He should be going ahead of his 29th-round ADP.

19. Brett Lawrie, Chicago White Sox

SEASON HR R RBI SB AVG
2014 12 27 38 0 .247
2015 16 64 60 5 .260
2016 (PROJ.) 21 58 60 2 .252

Strikeouts have long been Lawrie's problem at the major-league level and they trended in the wrong direction again last season. Chicago's addition of 3B Todd Frazier will push Lawrie over to second base full time. He's a risky pick due to the possibility he enters into a platoon situation against lefties only.

20. Daniel Murphy, Washington Nationals

SEASON HR R RBI SB AVG
2014 9 79 57 13 .289
2015 14 56 73 2 .281
2016 (PROJ.) 10 53 65 7 .288

Murphy is highly unlikely to repeat last season's power numbers, and his upside will be limited by hitting behind OF Bryce Harper in the Nationals' order. He'll be over-drafted based on last year's postseason performance, and owners shouldn't be buying into the hype at his current mid-round price.

21. Neil Walker, New York Mets

SEASON HR R RBI SB AVG
2014 23 74 76 2 .271
2015 16 69 71 4 .269
2016 (PROJ.) 13 61 55 2 .265

Walker's power numbers will drop with the move to Citi Field in New York. He's not a threat on the basepaths, though can get on base consistently. He's a similar player to Murphy, but carries more appeal due to the fact that he should be available a few rounds later.

22. Devon Travis, Toronto Blue Jays

SEASON HR R RBI SB AVG
2014 -- -- -- -- --
2015 8 38 35 3 .304
2016 (PROJ.) 10 56 42 8 .291

Travis won't resume baseball activities until April, pushing his likely return to game action back to May. Even once back and healthy, he may lose some playing time if 2B/SS Ryan Goins hits well to start the season. Travis should be drafted late in AL-only leagues, but left for waivers in mixed leagues.

23. Trea Turner, Washington Nationals

SEASON HR R RBI SB AVG
2014 -- -- -- -- --
2015 1 5 1 2 .225
2016 (PROJ.) 7 52 56 20 .288

Turner will have a shot to win the starting job at shortstop out of Spring Training, and he'll shoot up the ranks if he does. With the expectation of his debut not coming until late April or early May, he's best left for NL-only leagues at the moment. Keep a close eye on his spring.

24. Logan Forsythe, Tampa Bay Rays

SEASON HR R RBI SB AVG
2014 6 32 26 2 .223
2015 17 69 68 9 .281
2016 (PROJ.) 12 60 57 8 .261

An inflated BABIP led to an overly high batting average, though the breakout power showing was promising. The Rays' offense is largely unreliable entering the season, and Forsythe should be left for the latter rounds of AL-only leagues, and the waiver wire in mixed leagues.

25. Jedd Gyorko, St. Louis Cardinals

SEASON HR R.RBI SB AVG
2014 10 37 51 3 .210
2015 16 34 57 0 .247
2016 (PROJ.) 13 51 54 2 .251

Gyorko will receive the bulk of the starts at shortstop while Cardinals SS Jhonny Peralta is sidelined by injury. How he performs during that time will dictate how many starts he receives after Peralta's return. He's worthy of a starting second baseman selection in NL-only leagues, but he's better suited as a middle infielder in mixed leagues. Leave him for the late rounds in both.

26. Howie Kendrick, Los Angeles Dodgers

SEASON HR R RBI SB AVG
2014 7 85 75 14 .293
2015 9 64 54 6 .295
2016 (PROJ.) 7 52 47 4 .291

It's unclear how much playing time Kendrick will see in 2016 with the Dodgers' glut of infielders. He can still hit for a respectable average, but the power and speed are both gone, making him a waiver-wire leftover in all but the deepest leagues.

27. Brandon Phillips, Cincinnati Reds

SEASON HR R RBI SB AVG
2014 8 44 51 2 .266
2015 12 69 70 23 .294
2016 (PROJ.) 8 52 47 16 .272

If healthy, Phillips can still manage a respectable stolen base total, but the power and average are evaporating. With a lower average, he'll score even fewer runs than he would have while in an unimpressive Reds batting order.

▼28. Scooter Gennett, Milwaukee Brewers

SEASON HR R RBI SB AVG
2014 9 55 54 6 .289
2015 6 42 29 1 .264
2016 (PROJ.) 8 57 42 3 .263

Gennett is mostly a platoon option against right-handed pitching, though he'll face enough of those throughout the season to be of some value. He's a middle infielder in NL-only leagues and a mid-season injury replacement in mixed leagues.

29. Brock Holt, Boston Red Sox

SEASON HR R RBI SB AVG
2014 4 68 29 12 .281
2015 2 56 45 8 .280
2016 (PROJ.) 4 59 53 11 .271

Purely a waiver player, Holt will need to hit near the top of the Boston lineup on days when he draws in to warrant fantasy consideration. He's a total utility player, but there are enough elder statesmen for him to occasionally spell in the Red Sox order for him to receive fairly regular playing time. He won't kill a batting average in the event of an injury.

30. Martin Prado, Miami Marlins

SEASON HR R RBI SB AVG
2014 12 62 58 3 .282
2015 9 52 63 1 .288
2016 (PROJ.) 11 57 48 7 .279

Prado holds some appeal in NL-only leagues, but his upside is limited while hitting at the bottom of an unimpressive Marlins order. He'll need to start stealing more bases in order to be relevant - something that's unlikely to happen at this stage.

Daily Newsletter

Get the latest trending sports news daily in your inbox