Skip to content

MLB Positional Fantasy Rankings: Starting Pitchers (Part 3)

Denny Medley / Reuters

Here are theScore's 2016 fantasy starting pitcher rankings (projections provided by Steamer (via Fangraphs) and theScore staff):

Positional Rankings
C | 1B | 2B | 3B | SS | OF1 | OF2 | OF3 | DH | SP1 | SP2 | SP3 | RP

51. John Lackey, Chicago Cubs

SEASON W-L ERA WHIP K BB
2014 14-10 3.82 1.28 164 47
2015 13-10 2.77 1.21 175 53
2016 (PROJ.) 14-11 3.89 1.27 157 64

A change of scenery likely won't have a significant impact on Lackey's fantasy stats, though he'll be in line for a boatload of wins behind that lineup.

52. Julio Teheran, Atlanta Braves

SEASON W-L ERA WHIP K BB
2014 14-13 2.89 1.08 186 51
2015 11-8 4.04 1.31 171 73
2016 (PROJ.) 10-13 3.91 1.28 175 68

Teheran should fare better than he did last year, but only modestly. A lack of run support will torpedo his chances of getting back to the 14-win mark.

53. Taijuan Walker, Seattle Mariners

SEASON W-L ERA WHIP K BB
2014 2-3 2.61 1.29 34 18
2015 11-8 4.56 1.20 157 40
2016 (PROJ.) 12-9 4.01 1.18 155 40

If Walker can cut his home runs allowed - he had 25 in 169 2/3 innings last season - he'll be a top-50 option. Snag him as a high-upside SP6.

54. Gio Gonzalez, Washington Nationals

SEASON W-L ERA WHIP K BB
2014 10-10 3.57 1.20 162 56
2015 11-8 3.79 1.42 169 69
2016 (PROJ.) 12-10 3.97 1.43 160 72

Gonzalez posted his lowest K/9 rate since 2010 last season, while his BB/9 climbed back to 3.5. He's a high-risk SP6 who will likely go earlier.

55. Jaime Garcia, St. Louis Cardinals

SEASON W-L ERA WHIP K BB
2014 3-1 4.12 1.05 39 7
2015 10-6 2.43 1.05 97 30
2016 (PROJ.) 11-7 3.84 1.26 128 47

Injuries have limited Garcia to 36 starts over three seasons. He could be a sneaky play in the 16th-18th rounds, but prepare for fewer than 30 starts.

56. Yordano Ventura, Kansas City Royals

SEASON W-L ERA WHIP K BB
2014 14-10 3.20 1.30 159 69
2015 13-8 4.08 1.30 156 58
2016 (PROJ.) 13-11 3.96 1.31 160 66

Ventura was run-unlucky last season, but remains a solid SP 5-6 thanks to decent BB and K rates and low HR allowed totals.

57. Marco Estrada, Toronto Blue Jays

SEASON W-L ERA WHIP K BB
2014 7-6 4.36 1.20 127 44
2015 13-8 3.13 1.04 131 55
2016 (PROJ.) 13-10 4.01 1.14 137 60

Estrada outpitched his FIP by more than 1.25 last season; expect a major course correction in 2016, though he's still a solid SP6.

58. Joe Ross, Washington Nationals

SEASON W-L ERA WHIP K BB
2014 -- -- -- -- --
2015 5-5 3.64 1.11 69 21
2016 (PROJ.) 9-7 3.81 1.21 115 33

Reach for Ross if it appears he'll see a full complement of starts; he has major upside, but will likely face competition for starts heading into 2016.

59. Patrick Corbin, Arizona Diamondbacks

SEASON W-L ERA WHIP K BB
2014 -- -- -- -- --
2015 6-5 3.60 1.27 78 17
2016 (PROJ.) 11-8 4.06 1.30 155 66

Corbin was impressive in an abbreviated 2015 campaign, and should return fair value as a 17th- to 19th-round pick in standard drafts.

60. Kyle Hendricks, Chicago Cubs

SEASON W-L ERA WHIP K BB
2014 7-2 2.46 1.08 47 15
2015 8-7 3.95 1.16 167 43
2016 (PROJ.) 12-9 4.12 1.19 170 52

Hendricks flashed big-time potential in 2015, and still has room for improvement; he's a high-upside SP6 who could finish as a top-50 starter.

61. Kenta Maeda, Los Angeles Dodgers

SEASON W-L ERA WHIP K BB
2014 (JPCL) 11-9 2.60 1.10 161 41
2015 (JPCL) 15-8 2.09 1.01 175 41
2016 (PROJ.) 11-9 3.88 1.22 148 57

Maeda is a mystery, which means he'll likely be overdrafted - but with a rotation spot all but secure, you could do worse in the 17th-19th rounds.

62. Wei-Yin Chen, Miami Marlins

SEASON W-L ERA WHIP K BB
2014 16-6 3.54 1.23 136 35
2015 11-8 3.34 1.22 153 41
2016 (PROJ.) 11-11 3.86 1.25 149 47

Chen has been surprisingly reliable the past two seasons, and gains some upside with the move to Miami; he's an underrated SP6.

63. Jason Hammel, Chicago Cubs

SEASON W-L ERA WHIP K BB
2014 10-11 3.47 1.12 158 44
2015 10-7 3.74 1.16 172 40
2016 (PROJ.) 10-9 3.99 1.24 150 53

While Hammel saw a K/9 jump last season, everything else was rather ordinary; he's in the SP6 conversation, but only if his strikeout rate holds.

64. Mike Leake, St. Louis Cardinals

SEASON W-L ERA WHIP K BB
2014 11-13 3.70 1.25 164 50
2015 11-10 3.70 1.16 119 49
2016 (PROJ.) 12-9 3.75 1.18 135 47

Leake should see most of his statistics remain level, but he simply doesn't strike out enough batters to warrant more than SP6 consideration.

65. Aaron Sanchez, Toronto Blue Jays

SEASON W-L ERA WHIP K BB
2014 2-2 1.09 0.70 27 9
2015 7-6 3.22 1.28 61 44
2016 (PROJ.) 12-9 4.05 1.33 148 71

If Sanchez moves to the Toronto rotation, he'll be one of the most high-risk, high-reward picks among pitchers taken in the back end of standard drafts.

66. Trevor Bauer, Cleveland Indians

SEASON W-L ERA WHIP K BB
2014 5-8 4.18 1.38 143 60
2015 11-12 4.55 1.31 170 79
2016 (PROJ.) 12-10 4.01 1.27 179 78

He's a wild one, but Bauer's strikeout potential is undeniable. Expect enough improvement in his BB/9 rate to make him a viable SP6-7.

67. Kevin Gausman, Baltimore Orioles

SEASON W-L ERA WHIP K BB
2014 7-7 3.57 1.32 88 38
2015 4-7 4.25 1.23 103 29
2016 (PROJ.) 12-9 4.12 1.19 148 47

If he can cut down on home runs allowed, Gausman should be a nice sleeper option at the back end of standard fantasy drafts.

68. Aaron Nola, Philadelphia Phillies

SEASON W-L ERA WHIP K BB
2014 -- -- -- -- --
2015 6-2 3.59 1.20 68 19
2016 (PROJ.) 10-12 4.15 1.24 158 56

Nola has a bright future, though that it may not come to fruition in 2016; he's a nice speculative pick, but owners should expect a few bumps along the way.

69. Andrew Heaney, Los Angeles Angels

SEASON W-L ERA WHIP K BB
2014 0-4 5.83 1.33 20 7
2015 6-4 3.49 1.20 78 28
2016 (PROJ.) 11-10 3.82 1.23 124 57

Heaney should provide owners with decent ERA and WHIP, but his strikeout rates have been unflattering - and that cripples his overall value.

70. Edinson Volquez, Kansas City Royals

SEASON W-L ERA WHIP K BB
2014 13-7 3.04 1.23 140 71
2015 13-9 3.55 1.31 155 72
2016 (PROJ.) 13-10 4.05 1.34 152 81

Volquez is effectively wild, but sooner or later the walks, HBPs and wild pitches will catch up with him. His low K rate makes him an SP7.

71. Jimmy Nelson, Milwaukee Brewers

SEASON W-L ERA WHIP K BB
2014 2-9 4.93 1.46 57 19
2015 11-13 4.11 1.29 148 65
2016 (PROJ.) 10-12 4.13 1.29 157 69

Nelson will struggle to record double-digit victories on this team, but should strike out enough hitters to be considered at the end of mixed-league drafts.

72. Eduardo Rodriguez, Boston Red Sox

SEASON W-L ERA WHIP K BB
2014 -- -- -- -- --
2015 10-6 3.85 1.29 98 37
2016 (PROJ.) 12-10 4.17 1.28 131 54

Rodriguez had a decent rookie campaign, but a low K rate reduces his value. He has upside, but don't reach higher than your SP7 slot for him.

73. Anthony DeSclafani, Cincinnati Reds

SEASON W-L ERA WHIP K BB
2014 2-2 6.27 1.36 26 5
2015 9-13 4.05 1.35 151 55
2016 (PROJ.) 10-12 4.07 1.33 157 56

DeSclafani becomes the Reds' No. 2 starter, and should work enough innings - and make enough progress - to be a solid SP7 in standard drafts.

74. Anibal Sanchez, Detroit Tigers

SEASON W-L ERA WHIP K BB
2014 8-5 3.43 1.10 102 30
2015 10-10 4.99 1.28 138 49
2016 (PROJ.) 11-10 4.20 1.22 130 44

Sanchez might not lead the American League in home runs allowed again, but his best days are clearly behind him. Draft him as a matchups-only SP7.

75. Rich Hill, Oakland Athletics

SEASON W-L ERA WHIP K BB
2014 0-0 3.38 2.44 9 6
2015 2-1 1.55 0.66 36 5
2016 (PROJ.) 9-11 4.30 1.34 110 46

Hill could finish as the SP30, or as the SP130. His range of outcomes is wider than anyone's. Feeling lucky? Take a shot with one of your final three picks.

Daily Newsletter

Get the latest trending sports news daily in your inbox