Skip to content

10-Team Fantasy Hockey Mock Draft

Ronald C. Modra/NHL / Getty Images Sport / Getty

Follow theScore's fantasy feed on Twitter (@theScoreFantasy) for the latest news, features and more. And download Squad Up, theScore's free-to-win-money sports game.

Members of theScore staff conducted a 10-team fantasy hockey draft in preparation of the 2016-17 fantasy hockey season. It is best to leave drafts right up until the start of the new year in order to have a better understanding of player roles and in an attempt to avoid any preseason injuries.

The members of the draft were: Esten McLaren, James Bisson, Josh Wegman, Jason Wilson, Neil Parker, Michael Clifford, Chris Meaney, Andrew Reid, J.P. Balladier, and Topher Smith.

The scoring categories for skaters are: Goals, Assists, Points, Power-Play Points, Shots on Goal, Faceoff Wins

For goalies: Games Started, Wins, Goals Against Average, Saves, Save Percentage, Shutouts

Positions are: 2 C, 2 LW, 2 RW, 4 D, 2 G, 4 BENCH

Round 1

Pick Player Owner
1 Sidney Crosby (C) Clifford
2 Alex Ovechkin (LW) Wilson
3 Patrick Kane (RW) Balladier
4 Jamie Benn (LW) Wegman
5 Connor McDavid (C) Meaney
6 Vladimir Tarasenko (RW) Reid
7 Johnny Gaudreau (LW) Smith
8 Steven Stamkos (C) Bisson
9 Tyler Seguin (C) McLaren
10 Joe Pavelski (C/RW) Parker

Analysis: No surprises in the opening round. Stamkos remains a major risk due to issues with blood clots. The upside remains for him to pose the greatest threat to Ovechkin's Rocket Richard Trophy defense. Seguin ranked sixth in points per game and was on pace for 83 points before his season was cut short by injury. He and Benn remain the best duo in the league.

Round 2

Pick Player Owner
11 Erik Karlsson (D) Parker
12 John Tavares (C) McLaren
13 Braden Holtby (G) Bisson
14 Brent Burns (D) Smith
15 Claude Giroux (C) Reid
16 Carey Price (G) Meaney
17 Jonathan Quick (G) Wegman
18 P.K. Subban (D) Balladier
19 Anze Kopitar (C) Wilson
20 Ben Bishop (G) Clifford

Analysis: Parker won the Karlsson sweepstakes. Not only did he secure the best offensive defenseman by a considerable margin, he landed a player in the second round with a legitimate shot to lead the league in assists, points and power-play points. Tavares has similar upside, but he'll have to adapt to a new batch of complimentary wingers once again.

Round 3

Pick Player Owner
21 Cory Schneider (G) Clifford
22 Patrice Bergeron (C) Wilson
23 Evgeny Kuznetsov (C) Balladier
24 Corey Perry (RW) Wegman
25 Artemi Panarin (LW) Meaney
26 Logan Couture (C) Reid
27 Evgeni Malkin (C) Smith
28 Nicklas Backstrom (C) Bisson
29 James Neal (RW) McLaren
30 Dustin Byfuglien (D) Parker

Analysis: Schneider will provide excellent ratios in SV% and GAA, but he'll struggle to record wins in New Jersey. Malkin is an interesting pick, as he's likely be forced in the third-line center role for the Penguins. He'll still heavily feature on the power play. The battle between Kuznetsov and Backstrom will come down to who centers Ovechkin. Kuznetsov is the better goal-scorer.

Round 4

Pick Player Owner
31 Martin Jones (G) Parker
32 Kris Letang (D) McLaren
33 Nikita Kucherov (RW) Bisson
34 Corey Crawford (G) Smith
35 Pekka Rinne (G) Reid
36 Blake Wheeler (RW) Meaney
37 John Gibson (G) Wegman
38 Taylor Hall (LW) Balladier
39 Henrik Lundqvist (G) Wilson
40 Filip Forsberg (LW) Clifford

Analysis: Some interesting goalie selections here. Crawford may not be guaranteed his lofty win totals of years as depth at both forward and defense is a concern for the Blackhawks. Rinne will need to bounce back from one of his worst seasons, but the Predators' skaters will provide plenty of goal support. Gibson will finally have a full workload, but can he handle it?

Round 5

Pick Player Owner
41 Oliver Ekman-Larsson (D) Clifford
42 Nathan MacKinnon (C/RW) Wilson
43 Jack Eichel (C) Balladier
44 Wayne Simmonds (RW) Wegman
45 Shayne Gostisbehere (D) Meaney
46 Drew Doughty (D) Reid
47 Phil Kessel (RW) Smith
48 Jake Allen (G) Bisson
49 Brad Marchand (LW) McLaren
50 Mark Scheifele (C) Parker

Analysis: After scoring 24 goals and 63 points in his rookie season, MacKinnon has totaled just 90 points over 136 games in his past two campaigns. Expect a bounce-back with new Avalanche bench boss Jared Bednar. Marchand was the final player on the board with 40-goal potential. He lacks in assists but still tied for 35th in points last season.

Round 6

Pick Player Owner
51 Ryan Johansen (C) Parker
52 John Klingberg (D) McLaren
53 Max Pacioretty (LW) Bisson
54 John Carlson (D) Smith
55 Tuukka Rask (G) Reid
56 Sean Monahan (C) Meaney
57 Aleksander Barkov (C) Wegman
58 Shea Weber (D) Balladier
59 Roberto Luongo (G) Wilson
60 Jordan Eberle (RW) Clifford

Analysis: Having the opportunity to pair Klingberg with Letang was too good to pass up. My back end is coming together well with the players who ranked fifth and third, respectively, in defenseman scoring last season. Reid made his second gamble in net, pairing Rask with Rinne. The upside is incredibly high, but both are coming off disappointing seasons.

Round 7

Pick Player Owner
61 Mark Giordano (D) Clifford
62 Gabriel Landeskog (LW) Wilson
63 Roman Josi (D) Balladier
64 Ryan Getzlaf (C) Wegman
65 Devan Dubnyk (G) Meaney
66 Zach Parise (LW) Reid
67 Jason Spezza (C) Smith
68 Victor Hedman (D) Bisson
69 Torey Krug (D) McLaren
70 Marc-Andre Fleury (G) Parker

Analysis: Josi was an absolute steal. He ranked fourth in defenseman scoring last season while paired with Weber. He'll now skate with Subban at both 5v5 and on the power play, and was bargain going five rounds after his partner. Krug still tied for 19th in defenseman scoring in 2015-16, despite converting just 1.6 percent of his shots. He will score double-digit goals this season.

Round 8

Pick Player Owner
71 Jonathan Huberdeau (LW) Parker
72 Petr Mrazek (G) McLaren
73 Keith Yandle (D) Bisson
74 Joe Thornton (C) Smith
75 Daniel Sedin (LW) Reid
76 Rasmus Ristolainen (D) Meaney
77 Duncan Keith (D) Wegman
78 Aaron Ekblad (D) Balladier
79 Justin Faulk (D) Wilson
80 Tyson Barrie (D) Clifford

Analysis: I waited far too long on goaltending and am left hoping the Red Wings follow the trend of last season and give Mrazek the majority of starts over G Jimmy Howard. This was a dangerous strategy with games started as a weekly category in a head-to-head league. Faulk was a power-play monster last season, scoring 12 of his 16 goals at 5v4. It'll be difficult to repeat.

Round 9

Pick Player Owner
81 Ryan O'Reilly (C/LW) Clifford
82 Jakub Voracek (LW/RW) Wilson
83 Brandon Saad (LW/RW) Balladier
84 Alexander Steen (LW) Wegman
85 Tyler Toffoli (C/RW) Meaney
86 Jonathan Toews (C) Reid
87 Brian Elliott (G) Smith
88 Milan Lucic (LW) Bisson
89 Alex Galchenyuk (C) McLaren
90 Patrik Laine (RW) Parker

Analysis: With Yahoo! cutting back on positional eligibility this season, it's surprising to see O'Reilly still listed as a left wing. It's Clifford's gain, as he'll be able to plug the third-ranked player in FOW from last season as a third center. Elliott moves from a stout defensive system in St. Louis to a Flames team which had the worst overall goalie statistics in the league last season.

Round 10

Pick Player Owner
91 Rick Nash (LW) Parker
92 Craig Anderson (G) McLaren
93 Ryan Suter (D) Bisson
94 Kevin Shattenkirk (D) Smith
95 David Krejci (C) Reid
96 Matt Duchene (C) Meaney
97 Jake Muzzin (D) Wegman
98 Dylan Larkin (C/RW) Balladier
99 Max Domi (LW) Wilson
100 James van Riemsdyk (LW) Clifford

Analysis: Nash's tenure with the Rangers has been lackluster, but he is just two years removed from 69 points in the only season in which he played at least 70 games. Anderson started 60 games last season and managed to win 31 games. His .916 save percentage was right on his career average. He's a stable, but mediocre option.

Round 11

Pick Player Owner
101 Jeff Carter (C) Clifford
102 Kyle Okposo (RW) Wilson
103 Jonathan Drouin (LW) Balladier
104 Dougie Hamilton (D) Wegman
105 Brayden Schenn (C/LW) Meaney
106 Brent Seabrook (D) Reid
107 Patrick Sharp (LW/RW) Smith
108 Jaromir Jagr (RW) Bisson
109 Mark Stone (RW) McLaren
110 Mike Hoffman (LW) Parker

Analysis: Drouin has potential, as always, but he's a risk. He'll need to carry last season's playoff success through a full 82-game schedule. He's back in better favor in Tampa Bay and should have a spot on the left side of Stamkos. A pair of Senators' first-line wingers wrapped up the round. Stone is likely the safer option, but Hoffman has more upside.

Round 12

Pick Player Owner
111 Auston Matthews (C) Parker
112 Tyler Johnson (C) McLaren
113 Loui Eriksson (LW) Bisson
114 Andrew Ladd (LW) Smith
115 Alexander Radulov (RW) Reid
116 Boone Jenner (C/LW) Meaney
117 Sami Vatanen (D) Wegman
118 Jaroslav Halak (G) Balladier
119 Vincent Trocheck (C) Wilson
120 T.J. Oshie (RW) Clifford

Analysis: Matthews has plenty of talent, but the 2016 No. 1 pick is likely being drafted too high. He isn't the same caliber as McDavid, and he won't have as good of a supporting cast. He has 60-point potential, but Johnson has already had a 72-point season. Radulov is another big risk budding with potential. He had 26 goals and 58 point in his last full season in the NHL back in 2007-08.

Round 13

Pick Player Owner
121 Frederik Andersen (G) Clifford
122 Robin Lehner (G) Wilson
123 Sergei Bobrovsky (G) Balladier
124 Matt Murray (G) Wegman
125 Brendan Gallagher (RW) Meaney
126 Adam Henrique (C) Reid
127 Seth Jones (D) Smith
128 Marc-Edouard Vlasic (D) Bisson
129 Henrik Zetterberg (C/LW) McLaren
130 Nikolaj Ehlers (LW/RW) Parker

Analysis: Andersen, Lehner and Bobrovsky have more talent than their teams will likely allow them to display. Murray plays for the defending Stanley Cup champions, but he'll miss the start of the season and will need to fight for playing time with Fleury. Ehlers totaled 38 points in a 72-game rookie season; he'll start the year on the Jets' top line with Schiefele and Wheeler.

Round 14

Pick Player Owner
131 Cam Talbot (G) Parker
132 Connor Hellebuyck (G) McLaren
133 Thomas Greiss (G) Bisson
134 Jeff Skinner (LW) Smith
135 Semyon Varlamov (G) Reid
136 Morgan Rielly (D) TOR
137 Ryan Kesler (C) Wegman
138 Colton Parayko (D) Balladier
139 Alex Pietrangelo (D) Wilson
140 Ryan McDonagh (D) Clifford

Analysis: Talbot has a firm grasp on the starting job in Edmonton, but he'll still struggle behind a still porous defense. Hellebuyck has the inside track at the Jets' starting job, but it isn't yet guaranteed. He is the superior talent to Ondrej Pavelec and Michael Hutchinson.

Round 15

Pick Player Owner
141 T.J. Brodie (D) Clifford
142 Matt Niskanen (D) Wilson
143 Tomas Hertl (C) Balladier
144 Kyle Palmieri (RW) Wegman
145 Patric Hornqvist (RW) Meaney
146 Alec Martinez (D) Reid
147 Anton Stralman (D) Smith
148 Hampus Lindholm (D) Bisson
149 Gustav Nyquist (LW/RW) McLaren
150 Alex Goligoski (D) Parker

Analysis: Hertl had a career year in 2015-16, totaling 46 points with 21 goals. He'll center the Sharks' third line this season, between rookie Timo Meier and RW Joel Ward. After campaigns of 28 and 27 goals, Nyquist regressed all the way down to 17 last season. He has still shot over 13 percent for his career, and he should have more opportunities within the Red Wings' top six.

Round 16

Pick Player Owner
151 Adam Larsson (D) Parker
152 Dion Phaneuf (D) McLaren
153 Derick Brassard (C) Bisson
154 David Pastrnak (RW) Smith
155 Cam Fowler (D) Reid
156 Matt Dumba (D) Meaney
157 Jaden Schwartz (LW) Wegman
158 Sam Reinhart (C/RW) Balladier
159 Nick Leddy (D) Wilson
160 Cam Atkinson (RW) Clifford

Analysis: As team's rounded out their defense corps or their bench, safe plays were made at defense. Larsson will have to prove himself in Edmonton, but he'll log big minutes with the best forward corps he has ever had. Phaneuf is expected to be paired with Karlsson on the power play, after failing to tally a power-play goal last season.

Daily Newsletter

Get the latest trending sports news daily in your inbox