Patriots' lawyers strike back with lengthy rebuttal to Wells Report

by
Greg M. Cooper / USA TODAY Sports

Lawyers for the New England Patriots issued a lengthy, highly critical response to the Wells Report on Thursday in an attempt to add what the team describes as "context" to the NFL's investigation into the "Deflategate" scandal.

More bluntly, the document aims to poke holes in Ted Wells' conclusions and, ultimately, exonerate quarterback Tom Brady of any wrongdoing.

"The conclusions of the Wells Report are, at best, incomplete, incorrect and lack context," the Patriots' response, which can be viewed in full at WellsReportContext.com, begins.

"Inconsistencies in logic and evidence are ignored."

From there, the Patriots' rebuttal moves point-by-point through the Wells Report, identifying alleged inconsistencies and errors.

At times, the document veers away from credibility. For instance, the Patriots say references to "The Deflator" made in text messages between team employees were not about footballs but instead weight loss.

Brady is expected to appeal his four-game suspension before Thursday's deadline of 5 p.m. ET.

The Digest

Everything you need to know about the Wells Report

by theScore Staff

On May 6, Ted Wells released the findings from his investigation of the New England Patriots' alleged underinflating of footballs in their AFC Championship win over the Indianapolis Colts. Wells determined that it was "more probable than not" that Patriots personnel both participated in violations of league rules and were involved in a deliberate attempt to circumvent those rules.

Need to Know

  • As a result of the report, the NFL suspended Brady for the first four games of the 2015 season and fined the Patriots $1 million. New England will also have to forfeit its first-round pick in the 2016 draft as well as a fourth-round pick in the 2017 draft.

Related: Everything you need to know about Brady's suspension

  • Ted Wells, author of the Wells Report, defended his findings following the backlash after the Patriots' punishment was revealed. Wells shot back at detractors, saying "I think it’s wrong to question my independence because you don’t like my findings."
  • Once the report was released, newspapers were quick to poke fun at the findings, depicting everything from Brady as Pinocchio to Brady being physically deflated on their front pages.
  • Brady's agent Don Yee issued a scathing statement of the report questioning Wells' integrity and suggested investigators determined Brady's guilt before seeking facts and then built the report around that framework.
  • Even president Barack Obama took a jab at the Super Bowl champions when they visited the White House. "I usually tell a lot of jokes at these things, but with the Pats in town, I was afraid that 11 out of 12 of them would fall flat," Obama said.

Further Reading/Viewing

  • Juliet Macur of The New York Times believes the incident will forever tarnish Brady's legacy as one of the game's best players. [The New York Times]
  • Ian Crouch of The New Yorker examines the hit Brady's image will take not only from the revelation he likely cheated but the lies he likely told in the wake of his violations. [The New Yorker]
  • Ian O'Connor of ESPN.com dives deeper into what this mess means for Brady's credibility moving forward. [ESPN]
  • Dan Shaughnessy of The Boston Globe encourages the Patriots to come clean and start rebuilding trust, lest they tarnish their legacy irreparably. [The Boston Globe]
  • Peter King of The MMQB says if NFL commissioner Roger Goodell decides to penalize Brady with a suspension or heavy fine, it will forever alter Brady's perception among peers and fans. [MMQB]

Top Tweets

Advertisement