What the LeSean McCoy trade means for the Bills, Eagles

by Arun Srinivasan
Norm Hall / Getty Images Sport / Getty

Eleven years to the day after the Clinton Portis-Champ Bailey blockbuster trade, the Buffalo Bills and Philadelphia Eagles engineered one of the biggest deals in recent NFL history. 

Buffalo will trade linebacker Kiko Alonso to Philadelphia in exchange for running back LeSean McCoy, according to ESPN's Adam Schefter. The trade will be finalized next week. 

Although some have concluded the Bills instantly won the trade, there are layers to the deal that make it an equal transaction for both clubs. 

McCoy won the NFL rushing title in 2013, and he's easily the biggest offensive star the Bills have had since the Jim Kelly-Thurman Thomas era. The elusive running back is a desperately-needed weapon for Buffalo's stagnant offense, especially with the team preparing for C.J. Spiller's imminent departure. 

Fred Jackson has finally begun to show signs of fatigue at 33, and the Bills needed a new fulcrum for their run-heavy offense - a scheme that ought not to change much after the hiring of former 49ers offensive coordinator Greg Roman in the same capacity over the winter. 

Alonso, on the other hand, will be paired with Mychal Kendricks to give the Eagles one of the most formidable inside linebacker combinations in the NFL. For years, Philadelphia had ignored its genuine need for more depth among its front seven, and the 24-year-old is an instant upgrade over incumbent starters DeMeco Ryans and Emmanuel Acho

Again, it's not a clear win for the Bills, as the younger Alonso is significantly cheaper for the next two years. Monday Morning Quarterback's Andrew Brandt reported that Alonso will be paid a base salary of $746,000 and $942,000 respectively over the next two seasons. McCoy, on the other hand, will be owed $10.25 million, $6.9 million and $7.6 million over the next three years.

McCoy is a known commodity, and the Bills will be getting one of the league's most dynamic players. However, he also ran behind the best left side of any offensive line, with tackle Jason Peters and guard Evan Mathis clearing out space for the supremely agile running back. 

Buffalo's offensive line is porous and needs a heavy investment in new guards if they are to actualize McCoy's full potential. 

Alonso tore his ACL prior to his sophomore season, but in his first campaign finished second in Defensive Rookie of the Year voting. The rangy linebacker excels as a run-stopper but did an admirable job in coverage, and only stands to improve under Chip Kelly and Bill Davis's scheme. 

The Bills' defense excelled without Alonso, and Nigel Bradham's rapid improvement likely made the emerging star expendable. Philadelphia trusted its pace-and-space offense to keep ticking without McCoy, and freed up cap space to make the sum of its parts a lot stronger entering 2015. 

It appears that both teams came away as winners and can go to sleep Tuesday evening knowing they fixed a major deficiency entering free agency. 

The Digest

Everything you need to know about the McCoy-Alonso trade

by theScore Staff
Bill Streicher / USA TODAY Sports

The Buffalo Bills have rocked the NFL off-season, acquiring running back LeSean McCoy in exchange for linebacker Kiko Alonso.

Need to Know

  • The Bills wasted no time addressing McCoy's desire for a new contract, agreeing to terms on a five-year pact worth a reported $40 million. Approximately $26.5 million of that is guaranteed.
  • McCoy's relationship with Eagles head coach Chip Kelly became strained last season, according to former All-Pro running back LaDainian Tomlinson. McCoy felt like the Eagles weren't committed to him in their offense, and wasn't expecting to return to Philadelphia in 2015. 
  • The trade appears to make sense for both sides, with the rushing-starved Bills acquiring a premier rushing talent still in his prime and the Eagles securing the services of one of the top young linebackers in football at a much lower cost. 

Further Reading

  • ESPN's Phil Sheridan believes the deal is a sign that the Eagles are now Chip Kelly's team, saying "the picture has become much more complete. Kelly isn't just kicking back in his big office chair. He's remaking the Eagles' roster in the image that has formed in his mind." [ESPN]
  • Mike Sielski of the Philadelphia Inquirer says fans should get over what they may have thought of McCoy: "A lot of Eagles fans think of McCoy as he was or is. In a salary-cap league of abbreviated playing careers ... Kelly has to think of McCoy as he will be." [Philadelphia Inquirer]
  • Jerry Sullivan of the Buffalo News says the Bills are all in for 2015: "(Head coach Rex) Ryan believes you win with a dominant, attacking defense and a strong running game. They gave a little on defense here, but just added one of the top running back in the league." [Buffalo News]
  • Former running back Clinton Portis told NFL AM that the Bills are the clear winners of the trade. "I don't see Kiko Alonso turning out to be a J.J. Watt or a Ray Lewis, just dominating this conference. This is a trade I really don't understand. I don't think this is an even deal" [NFL.com]
  • NFL.com's Gregg Rosenthal took a more measured approach than Portis, suggesting that Alonso, Ryan, Bills fans and the Eagles' salary cap are all winners - and that McCoy, McCoy jersey owners and veteran Eagles linebacker DeMeco Ryans are all losers. [NFL.com]

Top Tweets

Advertisement