Skip to content

Value charts: Where can you afford to wait?

Matt Hazlett / Getty Images Sport / Getty

Fantasy football drafting is by no means a science. Superstars bust and 'nobodies' break out each and every year, allowing your Uncle Larry or Barb from your office to win the pool in their very first season playing any type of fantasy sports. It's unavoidably frustrating and incredibly fun at the same time.

While individual player performance will always remain highly variant, analyzing the different positions as a whole can help to mitigate risk or at least provide a look at where in drafts each position should be addressed. Here we'll look at ADP data, courtesy of MyFantasyLeague.com, from each of the past three draft seasons and compare them to end-of-season results.

Positions are broken down to starting fantasy positions, with the data focused on the top 12 quarterbacks and tight ends, the top 24 running backs (RBs 1 and 2) and the top 36 wide receivers (WRs 1, 2 and 3).

(NAs are players without an ADP; a value of 200 is used to determine average)

Quarterback

QB Avg. High Low
1 49 85 27
2 34 70 14
3 97 164 16
4 36 57 10
5 101 144 38
6 96 156 47
7 75 99 60
8 118 152 76
9 115 203 43
10 106 144 70
11 143 213 57
12 50 85 13

While there is a measure of safety in selecting the early quarterbacks, the chances of an early-round QB finishing as QB1 or QB12 were nearly identical; the earliest quarterback drafted in the three-year span finished as QB12.

Extremely late QB selections are unlikely to finish higher than QB8 but the first quarterback taken finished higher than QB4 just once in the past three seasons. Selecting a quarterback early on will help mitigate risk at the position but addressing other positions while waiting on quarterbacks offers similar floors and upsides.

Running Back

RB Avg. High Low
1 48 115 9
2 15 30 4
3 31 64 12
4 53 143 8
5 77 149 25
6 14 31 2
7 43 75 4
8 129 NA 38
9 46 100 17
10 98 135 32
11 80 131 3
12 90 187 18

Selecting an RB1 is difficult. The volatility of the position has been oft-discussed across the Internet and the gamble of picking a running back early in drafts is clearly displayed from the last three seasons.

The first running back selected never finished as the top-performing RB in the three-year sample, but selecting one of the first 12 RBs taken in a draft typically warranted an RB1 finish.

The number of late-round selections to turn in an RB1 season illustrates the importance of loading up on rushers as late-round lottery tickets. Because we can never be 100 percent on the success rate of handcuffs or sleepers, owners should choose quantity, especially at this most volatile of positions.

RB Avg. High Low
13 33 35 30
14 49 73 15
15 76 123 21
16 46 70 14
17 148 NA 89
18 113 170 23
19 146 150 139
20 104 NA 28
21 132 169 89
22 117 193 5
23 140 181 96
24 148 NA 86

Only 20 backs taken within the first 24 picks in each of the past three seasons finished the year ranking inside the top-24 at the position. Selecting a back with a high pick doesn't even guarantee an RB2 result, as it seems when running backs bust, they really bust.

With so many late-round RBs climbing their way up the standings every year, owners need to stock their bench with players beginning the season as the second or third option on the depth chart of their respective NFL team. These players should be stashed for the first couple weeks of the season, as they may not always receive an immediate opportunity.

Wide Receiver

WR Avg. High Low
1 46 100 9
2 21 25 15
3 30 65 9
4 38 85 11
5 68 167 14
6 30 39 18
7 97 157 65
8 34 61 19
9 98 131 72
10 50 70 18
11 93 114 57
12 31 33 28

There are two major takeaways from the three-year sample of WR1 performances. High draft picks have typically lived up to their billing and few late-round picks have worked their way up to a high finish. Owners should be targeting the elite wide receivers early in drafts, and avoiding the temptation to gamble on rookies or lesser-known talents late in drafts.

WR Avg. High Low
13 56 93 14
14 114 182 40
15 52 89 8
16 65 107 30
17 104 187 56
18 100 178 37
19 62 78 39
20 116 158 43
21 133 NA 16
22 116 186 58
23 99 127 50
24 117 185 25

A few more late-round receivers were able to turn in a WR2 season, but most of the tier is made up of receivers who were drafted to serve the role. There is plenty of depth at the top of the wide receiver position.

WR Avg. High Low
25 117 NA 65
26 79 153 33
27 90 155 45
28 62 NA 37
29 152 179 114
30 184 NA 151
31 94 NA 22
32 118 NA 75
33 86 189 19
34 168 NA 114
35 141 NA 94
36 141 191 44

This is the tier where the undrafted wild-cards begin to emerge. Owners should pass on the overhyped rookies who see their respective ADPs soar during the preseason, and instead seek out some rookies who may have gone later in the NFL Draft but are in better situations to see immediate playing time or are in offenses with better quarterbacks.

Alternatively, owners can look at veteran receivers who are being written off too early by the majority of fantasy owners and are likely to rejuvenate their careers either on a new team or in a new role.

Tight End

TE Avg. High Low
1 24 33 15
2 122 170 61
3 124 NA 12
4 71 93 56
5 120 124 117
6 116 165 60
7 137 NA 30
8 106 161 63
9 141 163 104
10 104 133 72
11 144 NA 107
12 143 NA 84

The first tight end drafted finished as the top player at the position in two of the three years in the sample, while in 2014 the first TE selected finished the season as TE3.

Investing a lot of draft capital in a tight end is a safe move for locking up the best player at the position but waiting can return a near-equal amount of value, while addressing the more important fantasy positions with earlier picks.

Here's what to look for when targeting a late-round tight end.

Daily Newsletter

Get the latest trending sports news daily in your inbox