Skip to content

Fantasy: 12-team mock draft

Tom Szczerbowski / Getty Images Sport / Getty

The second of our offseason mocks addresses arguably the most popular league size. A 12-team league makes things a little more challenging, without forcing owners to get too desperate on the waiver wire.

As always, we're trying to make these mocks as real as possible, so we've included defenses and kickers.

This is a standard (non-PPR) scoring league with the following roster spots: QB, RB, RB, WR, WR, TE, FLEX, DEF, K, BN, BN, BN, BN, BN, BN.

Draft Participants: Ken Conrad, Andrew Joe Potter, Gino Bottero, David Chernish, David. P. Woods, Esten McLaren, Josh Ghatak, Josh Wegman, James Bisson, Justin Boone, Jason Wilson, Dan Wilkins.

Round 1

Pick Player Owner
1 Antonio Brown (WR1) Conrad
2 Odell Beckham Jr. (WR2) Potter
3 Le'Veon Bell (RB1) Bottero
4 Todd Gurley (RB2) Chernish
5 Julio Jones (WR3) Woods
6 DeAndre Hopkins (WR4) McLaren
7 Adrian Peterson (RB3) Ghatak
8 Ezekiel Elliott (RB4) Wegman
9 Dez Bryant (WR5) Bisson
10 A.J. Green (WR6) Boone
11 David Johnson (RB5) Wilson
12 Rob Gronkowski (TE1) Wilkins

Round 1: You might see a few minor differences in your home league, but this is a very chalk opening round. Miller and Robinson are the only other players worth considering in the first 12 picks ... For the people who take issue with a rookie going this high, my guess is that after the preseason Elliott's ADP will move into the top-six. The combination of his talent and situation with the Cowboys is just too good to pass up.

Round 2

Pick Player Owner
13 Lamar Miller (RB6) Wilkins
14 Allen Robinson (WR7) Wilson
15 Jordy Nelson (WR8) Boone
16 Jamaal Charles (RB7) Bisson
17 Devonta Freeman (RB8) Wegman
18 Brandon Marshall (WR9) Ghatak
19 Alshon Jeffery (WR10) McLaren
20 Doug Martin (RB9) Woods
21 Eddie Lacy (RB10) Chernish
22 Mike Evans (WR11) Bottero
23 Amari Cooper (WR12) Potter
24 Mark Ingram (RB11) Conrad

Round 2: Another WR-WR start for me. Green and Nelson have top-five potential with extremely high floors ... Freeman and Lacy are a couple of volatile selections in this round, but you'll likely need to pay this price to get them. Both have clear paths to RB1 numbers and significant red flags ... Ingram is a very underrated pick for Team Conrad at the end of the second round. He was the fourth-ranked fantasy back up to Week 12, before an injury cost him the rest of the year.

Round 3

Pick Player Owner
25 Demaryius Thomas (WR13) Conrad
26 Thomas Rawls (RB12) Potter
27 LeSean McCoy (RB13) Bottero
28 Keenan Allen (WR14) Chernish
29 T.Y. Hilton (WR15) Woods
30 C.J. Anderson (RB14) McLaren
31 Kelvin Benjamin (WR16) Ghatak
32 Sammy Watkins (WR17) Wegman
33 Brandin Cooks (WR18) Bisson
34 Jeremy Maclin (WR19) Boone
35 Cam Newton (QB1) Wilson
36 Latavius Murray (RB15) Wilkins

Round 3: Rawls said he expects to be ready for the first week of training camp, but players are always overly optimistic about their own recoveries. I'd like to see him on the field before I committed a third-round pick. Team Potter took him as their top RB, which is a very big gamble ... I wasn't excited by any of the running backs available, so I stuck with receivers and grabbed Maclin, who would likely be my Flex in this league. You always want to limit your risk in the first few rounds and I am confident Maclin will reach 1,000 yards and eight or more touchdowns once again.

Round 4

Pick Player Owner
37 Julian Edelman (WR20) Wilkins
38 Jarvis Landry (WR21) Wilson
39 Jordan Reed (TE2) Boone
40 Aaron Rodgers (QB2) Bisson
41 Devante Parker (WR22) Wegman
42 DeMarco Murray (RB16) Ghatak
43 Randall Cobb (WR23) McLaren
44 Carlos Hyde (RB17) Woods
45 Doug Baldwin (WR24) Chernish
46 Matt Forte (RB18) Bottero
47 Russell Wilson (QB3) Potter
48 Jeremy Hill (RB19) Conrad

Round 4: I would have considered Latavius Murray with this pick, but Team Wilkins (a life-long Raiders fan) scooped him up at the end of the last round. Not liking any of my other options, I chose to shore up the tight end position with Reed ... Taking a quarterback this early seems unnecessary with the depth at the position, but it's tough to argue with Rodgers' resume. He's finished in the top-two fantasy QBs in five of the last seven years ... Hill is an interesting choice here. Despite his struggles at times in 2015, he still finished with the 14th most fantasy points among running backs.

Round 5

Pick Player Owner
49 Greg Olsen (TE3) Conrad
50 Golden Tate (WR25) Potter
51 Michael Floyd (WR26) Bottero
52 Emmanuel Sanders (WR27) Chernish
53 Dion Lewis (RB20) Woods
54 Jordan Matthews (WR28) McLaren
55 Jonathan Stewart (RB21) Ghatak
56 Larry Fitzgerald (WR29) Wegman
57 Jeremy Langford (RB22) Bisson
58 Jay Ajayi (RB23) Boone
59 Ryan Mathews (RB24) Wilson
60 Eric Decker (WR30) Wilkins

Round 5: With so many receivers going early, there's still quality running back options on the board in the fifth round. Of course, none of them are without their warts, but Lewis, Stewart, Langford, Ajayi and Mathews all have a chance to reach low-end RB1 or high-end RB2 status if everything goes right for them ... I snagged Ajayi as my first running back. In addition to his aggressive running style, I have faith in Adam Gase's ability to get the most out of the Dolphins offense. An upgraded and healthy offensive line shouldn't hurt either.

Round 6

Pick Player Owner
61 John Brown (WR31) Wilkins
62 Frank Gore (RB25) Wilson
63 Matt Jones (RB26) Boone
64 Ameer Abdullah (RB27) Bisson
65 Donte Moncrief (WR32) Wegman
66 Allen Hurns (WR33) Ghatak
67 Andrew Luck (QB4) McLaren
68 Duke Johnson (RB28) Woods
69 Danny Woodhead (RB29) Chernish
70 Melvin Gordon (RB30) Bottero
71 Gio Bernard (RB31) Potter
72 Drew Brees (QB5) Conrad

Round 6: Plenty of RB talent lingering into the sixth round. Getting a clear starter with a strong chance to produce RB2 numbers is impossible to pass up. Gore and Jones are obvious picks here. Pass-catching backs like Johnson, Woodhead, and Bernard will be heavily involved in their offenses and offer a lot of value, as well.

Round 7

Pick Player Owner
73 Steve Smith (WR34) Conrad
74 Tyler Eifert (TE4) Potter
75 Kevin White (WR35) Bottero
76 Blake Bortles (QB6) Chernish
77 Tyler Lockett (WR36) Woods
78 Rashad Jennings (RB32) McLaren
79 Ben Roethlisberger (QB7) Ghatak
80 Carson Palmer (QB8) Wegman
81 Marvin Jones (WR37) Bisson
82 Chris Ivory (RB33) Boone
83 DeSean Jackson (WR38) Wilson
84 Tom Brady (QB9) Wilkins

Round 7: Through seven rounds, nine of the 12 teams have secured their starting QB, which is a little surprising given the depth at the position and the size of the league. That's the earliest I've seen QBs go off the board in a 12-team expert draft this season. As you'll see later on, there is value to be found at QB after the 10th round ... I was excited about Steve Smith returning for another season, until the interview where he said his main goal for coming back is to reach 1,000 career receptions. That comment reminded me that Smith is a 37-year-old coming off a torn Achilles and expectations should be held in check. The seventh round might be a little early for the veteran receiver.

Round 8

Pick Player Owner
85 T.J. Yeldon (RB34) Wilkins
86 Michael Crabtree (WR39) Wilson
87 Justin Forsett (RB35) Boone
88 Travis Kelce (TE5) Bisson
89 Kamar Aiken (WR40) Wegman
90 Delanie Walker (TE6) Ghatak
91 Sterling Shepard (WR41) McLaren
92 Derrick Henry (RB36) Woods
93 Julius Thomas (TE7) Chernish
94 Coby Fleener (TE8) Bottero
95 Isaiah Crowell (RB37) Potter
96 Karlos Williams (RB38) Conrad

Round 8: In general, regrets aren't a great thing to carry around in life, but my decision to go after a TE early led to major regret when I saw Kelce fall to the eighth round. Phenomenal value for Team Bisson with the 88th overall pick ... After an outstanding rookie season, Karlos Williams returned to the team out of shape and overweight. I'm not against going after a high-upside backup RB in the eighth, but there are others I prefer over Williams at this point.

(Editor's Note: After this draft was completed, Karlos Williams received a 4-game suspension for violating the league's substance abuse policy.)

Round 9

Pick Player Owner
97 Markus Wheaton (WR42) Conrad
98 Willie Snead (WR43) Potter
99 Torrey Smith (WR44) Bottero
100 Javorius Allen (RB39) Chernish
101 Corey Coleman (WR45) Woods
102 Tavon Austin (WR46) McLaren
103 Stefon Diggs (WR47) Ghatak
104 Tevin Coleman (RB40) Wegman
105 LeGarrette Blount (RB41) Bisson
106 Charles Sims (RB42) Boone
107 Laquon Treadwell (WR48) Wilson
108 Arian Foster (RB43) Wilkins

Round 9: Rookie receivers Coleman and Treadwell were selected in this round. Coleman should see more volume, but I give Treadwell a slight edge this year due to his red-zone upside ... After ignoring running backs in the opening four rounds, I took my fifth straight RB. Strength in numbers will hopefully result in at least two players in that group turning into reliable fantasy starters.

Round 10

Pick Player Owner
109 Chris Johnson (RB44) Wilkins
110 Antonio Gates (TE8) Wilson
111 Eli Manning (QB10) Boone
112 Dorial Green-Beckham (WR49) Bisson
113 Dwayne Allen (TE9) Wegman
114 Vincent Jackson (WR50) Ghatak
115 C.J. Prosise (RB45) McLaren
116 Kenneth Dixon (RB46) Woods
117 Devin Funchess (WR51) Chernish
118 Jordan Howard (RB47) Bottero
119 Shane Vereen (RB48) Potter
120 Philip Rivers (QB11) Conrad

Round 10: Through 10 rounds, Team Woods hasn't selected a QB or a TE, which is a strategy that can work, but it puts a lot of pressure on your picks at those positions. In the meantime, he's loaded up at RB and WR ... Some owners like to take a second quarterback, but unless you have doubts about your starter, there isn't much to gain from wasting a bench spot on a backup QB. Team Conrad has Drew Brees, so didn't really need Philip Rivers.

Round 11

Pick Player Owner
121 Gary Barnidge (TE10) Conrad
122 Travis Benjamin (WR52) Potter
123 Alex Collins (RB49) Bottero
124 Josh Doctson (WR53) Chernish
125 Ladarius Green (TE11) Woods
126 Wendall Smallwood (RB50) McLaren
127 Bilal Powell (RB51) Ghatak
128 DeAngelo Williams (RB52) Wegman
129 Theo Riddick (RB53) Bisson
130 DeAndre Washington (RB54) Boone
131 Chris Thompson (RB55) Wilson
132 Devontae Booker (RB56) Wilkins

Round 11: Barnidge and Green lasting till the 11th round is downright criminal. Team Woods' decision to wait on the position pays off, as he secures Green, who is set up for a breakout season with his new team in Pittsburgh.

Round 12

Pick Player Owner
133 Josh Gordon (WR54) Wilkins
134 Ronnie Hillman (RB57) Wilson
135 Phillip Dorsett (WR55) Boone
136 Michael Thomas (WR56) Bisson
137 Kenyan Drake (RB58) Wegman
138 Seattle Seahawks (DEF1) Ghatak
139 Alfred Morris (RB59) McLaren
140 Zach Ertz (TE12) Woods
141 Darren Sproles (RB60) Chernish
142 Mike Wallace (WR57) Bottero
143 Eric Ebron (TE13) Potter
144 James Starks (RB61) Conrad

Round 12: The Seahawks get the honor of being the first defense selected, which will likely be the case in most drafts. With few players in this round moving the needle, it made sense for Team Ghatak to get out early and grab the defense he wanted.

Round 13

Pick Player Owner
145 Arizona Cardinals (DEF2) Conrad
146 Denver Broncos (DEF3) Potter
147 Tyrod Taylor (QB14) Bottero
148 Victor Cruz (WR58) Chernish
149 Derek Carr (QB15) Woods
150 Jimmy Graham (TE15) McLaren
151 Jameis Winston (QB16) Ghatak
152 Jerick McKinnon (RB62) Wegman
153 Tony Romo (QB17) Bisson
154 Josh Ferguson (RB63) Boone
155 Andy Dalton (QB18) Wilson
156 Breshad Perriman (WR59) Wilkins

Round 13: The 13th round passes without Team Wilkins taking a backup QB to pair with Brady. While it's easy to find a decent fill-in on the waiver wire, Team Wilkins is pot committed on the Patriots with Brady, Edelman, and Gronk. Let's hope his team can survive the first month of the season ... Team Wegman ends up with three of the best handcuff RBs out there in Tevin Coleman, DeAngelo Williams, and Jerick McKinnon ... Remember when we talked about the QBs available late in drafts? Romo, Winston, Carr, and Taylor in the 13th round are the perfect example of that.

Round 14

Pick Player Owner
157 Houston Texans (DEF4) Wilkins
158 Kansas City Chiefs (DEF5) Wilson
159 Carolina Panthers (DEF6) Boone
160 Los Angeles Rams (DEF7) Bisson
161 Stephen Gostkowski (K1) Wegman
162 Austin Seferian-Jenkins (TE16) Ghatak
163 Philadelphia Eagles (DEF8) McLaren
164 Minnesota Vikings (DEF9) Woods
165 Cincinnati Bengals (DEF10) Chernish
166 New York Jets (DEF11) Bottero
167 Kirk Cousins (QB19) Potter
168 Graham Gano (K2) Conrad

Round 15

Pick Player Owner
169 Chris Hogan (WR) Conrad
170 Steven Hauschka (K3) Potter
171 Justin Tucker (K4) Bottero
172 Dan Bailey (K5) Chernish
173 Mason Crosby (K6) Woods
174 Adam Vinatieri (K7) McLaren
175 Chandler Catanzaro (K8) Ghatak
176 Green Bay Packers (DEF12) Wegman
177 Blair Walsh (K9) Bisson
178 Josh Brown (K10) Boone
179 Brandon McManus (K11) Wilson
180 Sebastian Janikowski (K12) Wilkins

Daily Newsletter

Get the latest trending sports news daily in your inbox