NFLPA requests Roger Goodell recuse himself from Tom Brady appeal

by
Lucy Nicholson / Reuters

Looking to have the league appoint an independent arbitrator to hear Tom Brady's four-game suspension appeal, the NFLPA has formally requested that commissioner Roger Goodell recuse himself from the case.

The NFLPA cites "procedural violations" of the collective bargaining agreement and its desire to call Goodell as a witness in the appeal as reasons why the commissioner is unfit to preside over Brady's hearing.

"The players also believe that the commissioner's history of inconsistently issuing discipline against our players makes him ill-suited to hear this appeal in a fair-minded manner," the union stated in its press release.

Goodell maintains the power to serve as the arbitrator in all disciplinary appeals, and as Ian Rapoport of NFL Network reports, the commissioner is unlikely to step aside despite the union's request.

On the surface, given his approval of the initial discipline, Goodell opting to hear the appeal could limit Brady's chances of having his suspension reduced.

At the same time, having the opportunity to meet directly with Goodell rather than independent investigators could conceivably give the New England Patriots quarterback a better opportunity to state his case.

Patriots owner Robert Kraft announced Tuesday that the team will not appeal the severe punishment handed down by the league, but, according to Greg Bedard of MMQB.com, that does not include a deal regarding a potential reduction of Brady's suspension.

While Brady's case will likely be heard in the near future, the NFL and NFLPA have yet to announce a date for the proceedings to officially begin.

The Digest

Everything you need to know about Tom Brady's suspension

by theScore Staff

On May 11, the NFL suspended New England Patriots quarterback Tom Brady for the first four games of the 2015 season for his role in the "Deflategate" scandal involving underinflated footballs discovered during January's AFC Championship game against the Indianapolis Colts.

Need to know

  • The NFLPA filed an appeal of Brady's four-game suspension on his behalf on May 14, criticizing the NFL's "history of inconsistency and arbitrary decisions in disciplinary matters, " and requesting the appeal be heard by a neutral arbitrator.
  • The NFL announced on May 14 that Goodell will preside over Brady's appeal, the commissioner invoking his right to do so as stipulated in the CBA. "My mind is open," Goodell said in a statement on June 2 when he officially informed the NFLPA of his decision to hear the appeal.
  • Along with Brady's suspension, the Patriots were fined $1 million and must forfeit their first-round draft pick in 2016 and fourth-round draft pick in 2017.
  • Goodell spoke to the media on May 20, saying Kraft's decision to accept the NFL's penalties will have no impact on Brady's appeal. "I look forward to hearing from Tom," Goodell said. "If there's new information ... I want to hear directly from Tom on that."
  • The punishment for Brady and the Patriots came five days after the release of the Wells Report. The report declared it was "more probable than not" that Patriots personnel violated league rules by lowering the air pressure in game balls and that Brady was aware of the activities.
  • Ted Wells, author of the Wells Report, defended his findings following the backlash after the Patriots' punishment was revealed. Wells shot back at detractors, saying "I think it’s wrong to question my independence because you don’t like my findings."
  • The Brady suspension has already impacted the gambling world. The Patriots dropped from a six-point favorite in Week 1 against the Pittsburgh Steelers to a one-point favorite, while their odds of winning the AFC East also took a hit.
  • If Brady's four-game suspension is upheld on appeal, his first game back would come Week 6 against - oddly enough - the Colts.

Further Reading

  • theScore's own Arun Srinivasan examines the need for the league to come down hard on both Brady and the Patriots. While the punishment may have been overly harsh, it proves no one, even a four-time champ, is above the rules in the NFL.
  • Following a series of PR nightmares in relation to punishment doled out by the NFL (Ray Rice, Adrian Peterson), USA Today's Chris Chase argues the league finally got it right with Brady and the Patriots. [USA Today - For The Win]
  • On the other hand, Yahoo Sports' Frank Schwab makes the case that the NFL royally screwed up, presenting five reasons - including the lack of evidence against Brady - the decision was "dead wrong." [Yahoo Sports]
  • The MMQB's Peter King points out that the league wanted to show it doesn't play favorites by severely penalizing the Patriots. He also considers the impact of the situation on Brady's legacy. [The MMQB]
  • Sports Illustrated's Greg A. Bedard makes the case for Patriots' owner Robert Kraft leading the charge to replace Roger Goodell as commissioner. “I really don’t see how Robert is going to get past this with Roger,” a Patriots source told Bedard. [Sports Illustrated]

Top Tweets

Advertisement