NFL Week 12 betting takeaways: The contender shuffle

Michael Hickey / Getty Images Sport / Getty

We're running out of weeks where adjusting ratings is necessary. Eventually, teams are what they are. As we discuss each week, overreacting to one game is a fool's errand, but there are still a few teams who we have no clue what to make of, even after three months of football.

The Buccaneers' comeback win over the Colts keeps them atop the ratings - our tool for betting games each week.

Buccaneers 76 65-85
Bills 71 50-80
Packers 70 60-75
Cardinals 68 55-75
Cowboys 67 45-80
Ravens 67 45-75
Chiefs 66 45-80
Patriots 65 40-70
Rams 64 60-70
Chargers 64 50-75
49ers 62 50-70
Colts 57 35-65
Browns 57 50-65
Vikings 56 45-60
Bengals 55 35-70
Titans 51 50-65
Eagles 48 30-55
Broncos 47 40-55
Seahawks 47 40-60
Saints 46 40-60
Steelers 46 40-55
Washington 45 40-55
Raiders 44 35-55
Dolphins 43 30-55
Giants 39 30-50
Bears 36 35-45
Falcons 36 25-45
Panthers 35 35-50
Jaguars 31 25-35
Lions 26 20-35
Jets 25 20-30
Texans 24 15-25


The Packers could be without every offensive lineman known to mankind, and it wouldn't matter. We talk about the tight range they play within when different pieces are missing, but when this team is at full strength, they can beat anyone on the strength of Aaron Rodgers' arm. That shouldn't be a secret. Their ATS record doesn't lie, even if there were some weird covers early on.

The Rams are all in, and I'm getting closer to being all out on them this season. There are reports that Matthew Stafford is dealing with significant injury issues, and missing Robert Woods is a bigger deal than most people realize. Maybe consistently acquiring big-name players that other teams don't mind losing isn't the best strategy for roster building?

Having borderline incompetent coaching isn't a great strategy either. The Cowboys drop because Mike McCarthy is a problem, even while acknowledging that they were missing Amari Cooper and CeeDee Lamb. It's also notable that Dan Quinn's strategy played right into Derek Carr's hands. Jerry Jones admitted Ezekiel Elliott was compromised, and yet, Dallas kept running him out there, even after seeing Tony Pollard make the case that he's the fastest man alive with his 100-yard kickoff return touchdown.

The Patriots move up a little after beating up on the short-handed Titans, even though the number of rushing yards they gave up was a little concerning. But them being in the contender section is the biggest news ahead of their huge Monday Night Football showdown next week against the Bills.

The Spider-Man memes

The Vikings, Browns, 49ers, and Colts all attempted to win with the run game Sunday, and each had varying degrees of success in games that came down to the final play. We could copy-and-paste that sentence every week, but each team has a chance to contend as the weather gets colder.

The Vikings drop a little with Dalvin Cook injured, and the Browns do as well because their offense is a mess right now. If the Cleveland attack was close to average, the team would have won in Baltimore. The 49ers won and the Colts lost, but I actually have them both moving up, as Indy showed it could compete with our No. 1.

If you've paid any attention to the AFC West in the last decade, you knew to bet on the Broncos at home against the Chargers on Sunday. That's just what happens to Los Angeles in that spot, so we won't crush them for a loss that we should have seen coming, but we will drop them a couple of points. Next week's road game against the Bengals provides them an opportunity for another "zig" that would be appropriate in this NFL season.

Needing help

The Saints need to get healthy to get back above average. The Steelers got healthier but couldn't get a punt block - as they did in L.A. - to turn around this week's blowout. It's becoming clear that Pittsburgh can beat the Seahawks, Bears, Broncos, and (almost) Lions - but it takes more than a few bounces for them to keep pace with anyone better than that group.

We got a little high on the Eagles last week, didn't we? While we never liked them as 3.5-point road favorites, there was reason to back Philadelphia. We'll bring them back down to a more reasonable average expectation now.

The Panthers need a quarterback, but Cam Newton isn't it, and there are no more quarterbacks on the street that can come in to save the day. It was nice to fade the market overreaction to Newton taking the starting job, but we might not get a third chance after Carolina's bye week.

Finally, we congratulate the Jets on a win, which was nice for those of us that bet on the premise the Texans can't be favored over anyone, so all's right with the world there.

Matt Russell is a betting writer for theScore. If there's a bad beat to be had, Matt will find it. Find him on Twitter @mrussauthentic.

NFL Week 12 betting takeaways: The contender shuffle
  Got something to say? Leave a comment below!

Daily Newsletter

Get the latest trending sports news daily in your inbox