AL Manager of the Year Voting Ballots
| Name, Affiliation | Chapter | 1st | 2nd | 3rd | |
| Mel Antonen, MASNSports.com | BAL | Cash | Renteria | Baldelli | |
| William Lloyd Ladson, | MLB.com | BAL | Renteria | Cash | Melvin |
| Sean McAdam, Boston Sports Journal | BOS | Cash | Montoyo | Renteria | |
| Christopher Smith, Springfield Republican | BOS | Cash | Renteria | Montoyo | |
| James Fegan, The Athletic | CHI | Melvin | Cash | Montoyo | |
| Bruce Levine, WSCR Radio | CHI | Cash | Renteria | Melvin | |
| Mandy Bell, MLB.com | CLE | Cash | Renteria | Montoyo | |
| Joe Noga, cleveland.com | CLE | Cash | Renteria | Montoyo | |
| Jason Beck, MLB.com | DET | Cash | Montoyo | Renteria | |
| Cody Stavenhagen, The Athletic | DET | Cash | Melvin | Renteria | |
| Richard Justice, MLB.com | HOU | Renteria | Montoyo | Cash | |
| Jesus Ortiz, Our Esquina Sports | HOU | Cash | Renteria | Montoyo | |
| Mike Osegueda, Yahoo Sports | KC | Montoyo | Cash | Melvin | |
| Alec Lewis, The Athletic | KC | Renteria | Cash | Melvin | |
| Nobuhiro Saito, Nikkan Sports News | LA | Cash | Baldelli | Melvin | |
| Tomohiko Yasuoka, Jiji Press | LA | Cash | Melvin | Baldelli | |
| Do-Hyoung Park, MLB.com | MIN | Montoyo | Cash | Renteria | |
| John Shipley, St. Paul Pioneer Press | MIN | Cash | Baldelli | Melvin | |
| Anri Uechi, Kyodo News | NY | Cash | Renteria | Montoyo | |
| Mark Feinsand, MLB.com | NY | Cash | Montoyo | Renteria | |
| Eno Sarris, The Athletic | OAK | Cash | Montoyo | Renteria | |
| Josh Dubow, The Associated Press | OAK | Cash | Montoyo | Renteria | |
| Daniel Kramer, MLB.com | SEA | Cash | Renteria | Melvin | |
| Bob Condotta, Seattle Times | SEA | Renteria | Baldelli | Melvin | |
| Marc Topkin, Tampa Bay Times | TB | Cash | Montoyo | Renteria | |
| Juan Toribio, MLB.com | TB | Cash | Renteria | Montoyo | |
| Sam Blum, The Dallas Morning News | TEX | Cash | Montoyo | Baldelli | |
| Mac Engel, Fort Worth Star-Telegram | TEX | Renteria | Melvin | Baker | |
| Scott Mitchell, TSN | TOR | Cash | Montoyo | Baldelli | |
| Mike Harrington, Buffalo News | TOR | Cash | Montoyo | Renteria |