FIFA's saviour: Will Gianni Infantino be the answer to football's prayers?

by
OLIVIER MORIN / AFP / Getty

A small, bald lawyer is expected to revolutionise football, but high expectations are premature.

The election of Gianni Infantino is largely perceived as a new chapter for FIFA and for football in general, the start of a reform that will rid the beautiful game of corruption and will result in all 209 of the governing body's members holding hands and singing national anthems together. It's a nice idea, and the standard to which he is being held by so many people should be applauded.

That being said, it would be absurd to suggest Infantino will completely rid FIFA of the issues that have long plagued it. Can he usher in any meaningful change? That, too, may be unlikely.

Related: Gianni Infantino elected as FIFA president

First of all, it should be noted that almost anyone in Infantino's position would look like an angel given the alternatives. He is replacing Sepp Blatter, a man who believes homosexuals should refrain from sex at the 2022 World Cup and that race rows can be settled with simple handshakes. He was also running against Sheikh Salman bin Ebrahim al-Khalifa, a man accused of complicity in the systematic imprisonment and torture of Bahraini athletes during a bloody crackdown on pro-democracy protesters in 2011.

Related: FIFA avoids further disgrace with Sheikh Salman's defeat

None of that is to Infantino's discredit. It merely needs to be pointed out.

The question must be begged, however: Is Infantino, despite his clean hands and charm, the best person to lead FIFA into a brave new world? Just over half of the governing body's member associations seemed to think so, and many of those voted in his favour only after it was clear Prince Ali Bin Al Hussein was no longer in the running.

Then there's the issue of Infantino's ties to Michel Platini, who is banned from all football-related activities for six years due to a "disloyal payment." While the former certainly seems less corrupt than the latter, an apple-doesn't-fall-far-from-the-tree concern is more than justified.

If the benefit of the doubt is given to Infantino, and it's presumed he is indeed the best person to be FIFA's ninth president, the following question is simple: Why? He promises transparency and backed the new package of reforms that were passed before his election, but that didn't set him apart from the pack of other candidates.

Arguably the most defining component of his campaign, Infantino is an ardent supporter of putting more cash in the hands of FIFA's member associations, each of whom is promised $5 million over four years, while each of the six governing body's confederations is promised $40 million. The amounts are set in his slick-looking manifesto.

(Courtesy: The Guardian)

Infantino's plans for distributing money present a number of problems. Not only can it be viewed as a means of purchasing votes, but it is a continuation of Blatter's plan for FIFA at a time when football's governing body is supposed to be separating itself from its former kingpin. The worldwide representative organisation for all footballers, FIFPro, sees a problem.

From FIFPro's official website:

FIFPro takes a dim view of today’s FIFA election that leaves the new president, Gianni Infantino, entrenched in a governance structure and culture that is open to corrupt practices.

Despite a package of reforms approved today by FIFA, FIFPro fears placing increased power in the hands of FIFA's 209 member associations lies at the heart of the problem. These organisations are not representative of the game and, yet, wield enormous influence over issues that affect key stakeholders such as the players, fans, clubs, and leagues. The newly adopted reforms failed to address the fundamental issue of making football authorities accountable to the game's most important actors.

It's clear Infantino knows how to appease FIFA's member associations, and his desire to distribute funds among them falls in line with his wish to expand the World Cup to include 40 national teams.

Beyond his plans for empowering FIFA's member associations, Infantino can be defined by many other unpopular stances. He refused to rule out converting Blatter into FIFA's honorary president, openly admitting: "I respect very much all the work he did."

He refused to disclose his salary and spent €500,000 of UEFA's bank account on funding his globe-trotting campaign; he rejected criticism of UEFA's work on match-fixing, which continues to threaten the integrity of European football.

He was forced to deny a deal was done behind closed doors to be Sheikh Salman's general secretary; he wants each member association to be given an equal vote, which, again, doesn't separate him from Blatter or the pack of other candidates.

Transparency and reforms are all well and good, but Infantino shouldn't be given a passing grade just because he's a step up from Blatter or different than Sheikh Salman. He is faced with an enormous task in cleaning up FIFA, and, while his election is a cause for minor celebration, there is no reason to believe that he can restore the governing body's image or that he is a breath of fresh air from his predecessor.

Telling the football world that he'll be responsible for change is one thing. Now the real work starts. Now he has to deliver.

The Digest

Complete coverage of FIFA presidential election, Infantino's victory

by
Matthias Hangst / Getty Images Sport / Getty

There's a new chief in town.

Friday in Zurich, Switzerland, to the surprise of many, Gianni Infantino - the amicable Swiss-Italian administrator best known for his oversight of UEFA draws and mastery of several languages - was elected as the new president of FIFA.

Related - Gianni Infantino elected as FIFA president

In succeeding disgraced and deposed president Sepp Blatter, Infantino defeated Sheikh Salman bin Ebrahim al-Khalifa, the Bahraini candidate who went into the day as the consensus favourite to assume the role.

The election required a second ballot, as neither Infantino nor Sheikh Salman garnered the necessary two-thirds majority on the first ballot. That said, the opening ballot did, to the surprise of many, see the European receive 88 votes - three more than his favoured counterpart - which set the wheels in motion for his eventual victory.

His 115 votes easily outdid Salman's 88 in the second round of balloting, which required only a simple majority (104 votes) for a new leader to be crowned.

Here's everything you need to know from FIFA's presidential election:

All about the new boss

Gianni Infantino is moving up in the world. Gone are his ball-handling duties and his need to make unfunny jokes in an effort to fill dead air while on stage at UEFA draws. In their stead, the 45-year-old will now be tasked with overseeing the daily happenings in the world of football, and repairing the reputation of a governing body that has been crippled by corruption. Quite the promotion.

What happened to Sheikh Salman?

Considered the heavy favourite heading into the election, Sheikh Salman's bid to become FIFA's ninth president took a massive blow in the opening round of voting and never recovered.

Prince Ali never had a chance

The real star of the show

Tokyo Sexwale, the South African businessman and former prison mate of Nelson Mandela, delivered the most enrapturing speech of the candidates. He was funny and engaging ... and then he removed himself from the race for FIFA's top role in a brilliant mic drop to conclude his speech - and kick the day's proceedings into high gear.

What else happened at FIFA's extraordinary congress?

The election, though it was obviously the highlight of FIFA's extraordinary congress on Friday, was but one of 12 items on the agenda for football's governing body.

Advertisement