Skip to content

Smith's threes, Knicks' Wednesday performance eerily similar to 2011

Kelley L Cox / Reuters

Well, here's one from The Twilight Zone, courtesy of a commenter at the New York Knicks blog Posting and Toasting:

On March 17, 2011, the Knicks had a player shoot 9-12 from three point range for 29 points. Their second leading scorer in that game shot 10-19 from the field. Amare Stoudemire had 6 FGs and 5 fouls. As a team, they had 25 assists and allowed 99 points. The win brought them to 3 back of Atlanta in the loss column.

On March 26, 2014, the Knicks had a player shoot 9-12 from three point range for 29 points. Their second leading scorer in that game shot 10-19 from the field. Amare Stoudemire had 6 FGs and 5 fouls. As a team, they had 25 assists and allowed 99 points. The win brought them to 3 back of Atlanta in the loss column.

It seemed a little strange, so we went back and pulled the boxscore from March 17, 2011, a 120-99 Knicks win over the Memphis Grizzlies. Let's check the claim made by "bluecheese999," line item by line item.

3-Point shooter - 9/12 for 29 points
March 17, 2011: Toney Douglas was 9-of-12 on threes for 29 points
March 26, 2014: J.R. Smith was 9-of-12 on threes for 29 points
Verdict: True

Second leading scorer - 10/19
March 17, 2011: Carmelo Anthony was 10-of-19 for 28 points (Douglas led with 29)
March 26, 2014: J.R. Smith went 10-of-19 for 29 points (Anthony led with 36)
Verdict: True

Amar'e Stoudemire - 6 FGM, 5 PF
March 17, 2011: Stoudemire is 6-of-12 shooting with five fouls
March 26, 2014: Stoudemire is 6-of-10 shooting with five fouls
Verdict: True

Standings - 3 games back of Atlanta in loss column
March 17, 2011: At 35-32, the Knicks are three-and-a-half games back of Atlanta for the fifth seed in the East - four in the win column, three in the loss column
March 26, 2014: At 30-42, the Knicks are two games back of Atlanta for the eighth seed in the East - one in the win column and three in the loss column
Verdict: True

Knicks = 25 assists, Opponent = 99 points
March 17, 2011: The Knicks had 25 assists on 41 field goals; Memphis scored 99 points
March 26, 2014: The Knicks had 25 assists on 40 field goals; Sacramento scored 99 points
Verdict: True

Time is a flat circle
Verdict: True

Daily Newsletter

Get the latest trending sports news daily in your inbox