Report: MLB discussed idea of pitcher-only HR Derby

With all the hype surrounding pitchers who crush dingers and whether they're deserving of a spot in the Home Run Derby, MLB has had discussions about the idea of hosting a separate contest.

During Sunday night's game between the Los Angeles Dodgers and San Francisco Giants, ESPN's Buster Olney reported the idea has been floating around.

“There’s actually been talk about the idea of a pitcher challenge-type Home Run Derby,” he said, “where maybe that Madison Bumgarner faces Noah Syndergaard of the (New York) Mets.”

Earlier in the week, Bumgarner said he wanted to be in the Derby, and subsequently put on a show in batting practice to cement his case. He currently has 13 career homers, which is the most among active pitchers.

Related: Bumgarner wants to compete in HR derby

But his manager, Bruce Bochy, initially said there was no way he could allow his pitcher to risk injury. Olney says the concern isn't about Bumgarner participating, but instead if he has to hit multiple rounds.

Chicago Cubs ace Jake Arrieta added on to Bumgarner's comments, saying if the lefty gets to be in the Derby, he wants in, too.

Arrieta is currently batting .276, and the difference with his case is Chicago Cubs manager Joe Maddon is more open to the idea of allowing his pitcher to partake in the Home Run Derby than Bochy.